16. Agent Parity Execution Roadmap

Status For `develop`

On an open feature branch, checked items below describe the intended post-merge develop state for that branch. Merged PR links remain the authoritative evidence for items that already landed.

June 18, 2026 correction: the next parity train is feature-first. The BV-EF proof, receipt, and claim-readiness work is useful history, but it did not finish product parity. New work under parent #475 must ship concrete user/operator capabilities before adding more proof wrappers, benchmark-only endpoints, or claim-lift gates. Keep claim guardrails, but defer broad receipts, claim-ledger updates, source refreshes, and false-completion scans to one separate claim-readiness phase after the feature train lands.

Paired Research

full goal document: 20. Seraph Agent Parity And Exceedance Goals
execution prompt: 17. Full Production Parity Goal Prompt
competitor truth and source discipline: 18. Agent Competition Truth Table
claim gate: 19. Strategy Claim Ledger
world-class strategy: 17. Seraph World-Class Strategy
superiority program: 11. Superiority Program

Purpose

This file is the implementation-side roadmap for research document 20.

It answers how Seraph should implement the full parity and targeted exceedance goal without duplicating the closed M0-M9 milestone foundation, creating a second live queue, or drifting away from the guardian-workspace vision.

Active execution state remains in the GitHub Project, issues, and PRs. This roadmap owns durable feature sequencing, dependency logic, and claim boundaries. Proof gates are proportional safety and claim controls, not the workstream itself.

Execution Boundary

Research document 20 is the competitor-pressure overlay. This roadmap is the implementation sequencing layer. The GitHub Project is the execution layer.

Do not recreate M0-M9 milestone issues; those are foundation anchors.
Do not create duplicate issues for the completed proof anchors: #438, #439, #440, #441, and #467.
Do not parent new work under closed historical batch #422.
Do not create an ironclaw-* import family. IronClaw pressure is implemented as secure-capability-host proof.
Do not treat raw channel count, plugin count, provider count, or voice/media presence as parity.
Do not claim secure, private, production-ready, superior, best, fully at parity, or IronClaw-class unless 19. Strategy Claim Ledger allows that exact wording.

Board Receipts

Verified on June 9, 2026 through GitHub PR, issue, and Project GraphQL/API reads after post-merge reconciliation. #473 merged into develop at 2026-06-09T18:35:49Z; the proof-slice issues below were then closed with completion comments and their Project status fields were updated to Done.

GitHub closing metadata for PR #473 may still expose closed historical batch #422 from earlier PR body history. That is treated as a stale metadata artifact, not the active parent relationship. The active parent for this proof train was #468.

Issue	Role	Project item	Queue	Lane	Priority	Size	Status	PR	Code Review
#468 Batch BQ: agent parity proof execution train	parent hub for the merged proof train	`PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgvLeHs`	Now	Docs / Meta	P0	L	Done	Merged through PR #473	Passed
#467 P1: Guardian-safe multimodal and voice proof	closed multimodal/voice proof-governance traceability anchor implemented in the aggregate train	`PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgvLV0A`	Now	Presence and Reach	P1	M	Done	Not Ready	Not Ready
#470 Batch BR: durable workflow state after endurance canary	closed durable workflow state proof-slice traceability anchor implemented in the aggregate train	`PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgvMBK8`	Now	Runtime Reliability	P1	L	Done	Not Ready	Not Ready
#471 Batch BS: guardian arbitration and live-learning receipts	closed guardian arbitration proof-slice traceability anchor implemented in the aggregate train	`PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgvMBLE`	Now	Guardian Intelligence	P1	L	Done	Not Ready	Not Ready
#472 Batch BT: governed capability-pack hardening receipts	closed ecosystem hardening proof-slice traceability anchor implemented in the aggregate train	`PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgvMBLI`	Now	Ecosystem and Leverage	P1	L	Done	Not Ready	Not Ready

Post-DP execution receipt captured on June 12, 2026:

Parent issue #475: corrected to mark DN, DO, and DP complete, to state that DP closed only bounded release-gate evidence, and to link active post-DP issues #573-#580.
Completed issues #573-#580: ProjectV2 readback verified Status=Done, PR=Merged, Code Review=Passed, Priority=P0, Size=L, and domain lane assignment after PRs #582-#589 merged.
Verified lanes are Runtime Reliability for DQ, Trust Boundaries for DR, Presence and Reach for DS, Guardian Intelligence for DT, Embodied UX for DU, Ecosystem and Leverage for DV, Execution Plane for DW, and Docs / Meta for DX.

Post-DX stronger-proof roadmap receipt captured on June 13, 2026:

Parent issue #475 remains the single full production-grade parity completion parent; no duplicate parent was created.
New huge batch issues were created for the stronger evidence and live controls still blocking broad parity/exceedance wording: #590 Batch DY for live durable orchestration parity proof, #593 Batch DZ for formal secure runtime isolation and trust certification proof, #592 Batch EA for always-available reach and voice/media parity proof, #591 Batch EB for guardian learning and memory live controls, #597 Batch EC for dense operator control and cockpit certification proof, #596 Batch ED for marketplace package-security and ecosystem parity proof, #595 Batch EE for browser/computer-use live reliability and recovery controls, and #594 Batch EF for the final post-DX parity and exceedance claim-lift gate.
Each new batch issue is a PR-sized parent batch item with Queue=Next, Status=Todo, PR=Not Ready, Code Review=Not Ready, Priority=P0, Size=L, and the domain lane matching its proof area.

The parent hub #468 coordinated the aggregate proof train without splitting it into micro-issues. Merged PR #473 integrated the replay, cockpit, memory, workflow, reach, durable-state, guardian-learning, ecosystem-hardening, and multimodal/voice proof slices against develop:

#457 / PR #458: live long-horizon replay and proof substrate
#439 / PR #459: cockpit operator efficiency benchmark
#441 / PR #460: memory provider quality gate
#440 / PR #461: workflow endurance canary
#438 / superseded PR #462: one excellent reach channel canary, with accepted proof merged through PR #473
#467: guardian-safe multimodal and voice proof gate
#470: durable workflow state after endurance canary
#471: guardian arbitration and live-learning receipts
#472: governed capability-pack hardening receipts

Post-merge interpretation:

The proof-train issues demonstrate deterministic parity-floor coverage for the named proof areas.
They do not close the broader production-grade gaps listed in Development Status.
The child issue PR and Code Review fields intentionally do not mirror the aggregate PR; the parent hub owned PR #473.
Stale reach PR #462 was closed as superseded after #438 was closed through the aggregate proof-train receipt. Its Project item PVTI_lADOD4qAvs4BS6n3zgrw9ec is now Status=Done, PR=Merged, and Code Review=Passed because the accepted reach proof landed through PR #473, not because PR #462 merged.

Production-Grade Parity Execution Train

The proof train is complete, but the production-grade parity train is now tracked in GitHub rather than in this document as a live queue. Parent issue #475 owns the execution train and Project state. The issue bodies and Project fields are the active work-tracking layer; this section records the durable dependency order and proof intent.

Order	Issue	Production-grade gap	Proof gate
1	#476 Batch BV: production parity readiness, claim gates, and integration proof harness	Shared readiness rubric, claim gates, duplicate-issue guardrails, and aggregate proof contracts before implementation claims start.	`production_parity_readiness`, `/api/operator/production-parity-readiness`, claim-ledger check, Project receipt, duplicate scan.
2	#477 Batch BW: secure-host architectural isolation and privileged-path hardening	Live privileged-path hardening beyond deterministic secure-host choke-point proof, covering secret replay/redaction, browser recovery partitioning, private-network egress, extension revocation, workflow/provider replay trust drift, blocked claims, and recovery actions.	`production_secure_host_hardening`, `secure_capability_host_live_isolation_v2`, `/api/operator/secure-capability-host-hardening`, expanded trust-boundary receipts.
3	#478 Batch BX: production durable orchestration and multi-agent workflow control	Production-oriented long-running orchestration receipts beyond the v1 durable state kernel: leases, revision guards, idempotent transitions, trigger dedupe, unsafe-resume blocks, and delegated-artifact adoption gates.	`production_durable_orchestration`, `durable_workflow_engine_v2`, `/api/operator/durable-workflow-engine-v2`, cockpit recovery receipts.
4	#479 Batch BY: production reach/browser/voice hardening receipts	Production-oriented reach/browser/voice hardening beyond the native-notification canary and governed voice/media proof: paired external messaging identity, revocation, approval handoff, privacy redaction, degraded recovery, browser provider truth, session partitioning, crash recovery, page-drift replay blocking, and guarded voice/media correction/deletion/revocation paths.	`production_reach_channel_hardening`, `browser_computer_use_reliability_v2`, `guardian_safe_voice_media_runtime`, `/api/operator/production-reach-browser-voice`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
5	#480 Batch BZ: live guardian learning, intervention quality, and memory-provider outcome proof	Longitudinal outcome learning and provider maturity beyond deterministic arbitration/provider-quality gates.	`live_guardian_learning_quality`, `guardian_intervention_outcome_cohorts`, `memory_provider_ecosystem_maturity_v1`, `canonical_memory_reconciliation_v2`, `provider_usefulness_regression`, `/api/operator/live-guardian-learning-quality`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
6	#481 Batch CA: marketplace-grade capability lifecycle, review, rollback, and ecosystem maturity	Marketplace-grade install/update/downgrade/disable/rollback/review/quarantine/diagnostics/staged-rollout maturity beyond local governed-pack proof.	`marketplace_grade_capability_lifecycle`, `governed_capability_lifecycle_v2`, `capability_rollback_failure_diagnostics`, `/api/operator/marketplace-lifecycle-maturity`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
7	#482 Batch CB: production operator cockpit control and end-to-end parity verification	Dense long-work operator control and final train verification across the production parity batches.	`production_operator_control_parity`, `production_parity_train`, `/api/operator/production-operator-control-parity`, cockpit no-regression proof, final critic audit.
8	#491 Batch CC: live external orchestration and crash attestation	Recorded-live external orchestration and crash-study evidence beyond durable-orchestration v2 receipts, with honest provider identity, evidence-mode, idempotency, replay, side-effect, and recovery boundaries.	`live_external_orchestration_attestation`, `orchestration_crash_recovery_study`, `/api/operator/live-external-orchestration`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
9	#492 Batch CD: production isolation hardening and security incident proof	Production-isolation and security-incident evidence beyond secure-host hardening receipts, with honest deterministic/recorded-live worker-root, browser-profile, credential proxy, extension quarantine, red-team, incident recovery, credential rotation, and operator-notification boundaries.	`production_isolation_hardening_v2`, `privileged_path_red_team_gauntlet_v2`, `security_incident_recovery_drill`, `/api/operator/production-isolation-hardening`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
10	#493 Batch CE: live broad reach and production voice/media proof	Live broad reach and production voice/media evidence beyond Batch BY deterministic receipts, with honest provider identity, evidence mode, consent, pairing, revocation, rate limits, abuse handling, approval handoff, capture boundaries, provider-failure fallback, and cross-surface continuity boundaries.	`live_broad_reach_channel_attestation`, `production_voice_media_provider_runtime`, `cross_surface_continuity_recovery`, `/api/operator/live-reach-media-proof`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
11	#494 Batch CF: live human outcome and causal guardian-learning proof	Recorded-live human-outcome and causal guardian-learning evidence beyond Batch BZ deterministic outcome/provider receipts, with honest consent, anonymization, correction/harm/follow-through, bias limits, counterfactual attribution, reversible learning, and provider live-regression monitor boundaries.	`live_human_outcome_quality_study`, `guardian_learning_causal_attribution`, `memory_provider_live_regression_monitor`, `/api/operator/live-human-outcome-learning-proof`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
12	#495 Batch CG: third-party marketplace attestation and operations proof	Recorded-live third-party marketplace attestation and operations evidence beyond Batch CA deterministic lifecycle receipts, with honest provenance, signature, publisher, compatibility, dependency, vulnerability, incident, review-freshness, and package-count claim boundaries.	`third_party_marketplace_attestation`, `marketplace_operations_incident_drill`, `publisher_review_and_package_trust`, `/api/operator/live-marketplace-attestation-proof`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
13	#496 Batch CH: browser provider attestation and multi-operator usability proof	Browser-provider attestation and multi-operator usability evidence beyond Batch BY deterministic browser reliability and Batch CB operator-control receipts, with honest provider identity, evidence mode, session partition, credential/download/upload boundaries, degradation, recorded-live operator metrics, accessibility, keyboard paths, and fail-closed recovery drills.	`managed_browser_provider_attestation`, `live_multi_operator_usability_study`, `browser_computer_use_recovery_drill`, `/api/operator/browser-provider-usability-proof`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
14	#497 Batch CI: final source-backed parity and exceedance audit	Final source-backed readiness audit across current competitor evidence, production-train issues/PRs/Project fields, docs, claim ledger, residual risks, and Critic/Contrarian dispositions.	`final_source_backed_parity_audit`, `final_claim_ledger_reconciliation`, `operator_final_parity_readiness_report`, `/api/operator/final-parity-readiness-report`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
15	#505 Batch CJ: production SLA orchestration and exactly-once recovery evidence	Production SLA orchestration receipts beyond Batch CC, with provider windows, jitter budgets, failure injection, scoped effectively-once recovery, duplicate side-effect audit, and operator recovery controls.	`production_sla_orchestration`, `exactly_once_recovery_evidence`, `duplicate_side_effect_audit`, `/api/operator/production-sla-orchestration`, final-audit linkage, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
16	#506 Batch CK: independent secure-host review and isolation hardening	Stronger secure-host evidence beyond Batch BW/CD bounded receipts: independent review, live hostile drill receipts, isolation evidence matrices, credential/tool/browser/workflow boundary drills, and recovery authority truth while keeping hardware-backed/container-grade isolation unclaimed.	`independent_secure_host_review`, `live_hostile_isolation_drills`, `secure_host_recovery_authority`, `/api/operator/independent-secure-host-review`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
17	#509 Batch CL: broad reach, production voice media, and mobile execution	Stronger reach/media evidence beyond Batch BY/CE bounded receipts: broad channel SLA, production STT/TTS quality gates, mobile execution continuity, abuse/rate-limit operations, and cross-surface continuity.	`broad_channel_sla_operations`, `production_voice_media_quality_gates`, `mobile_execution_continuity`, `/api/operator/production-reach-voice-mobile`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
18	#507 Batch CM: independent guardian learning outcomes and memory parity proof	Stronger guardian-learning evidence beyond Batch BZ/CF bounded receipts: independent outcome cohorts, task-scoped causal attribution, bias/harm/follow-through review, long-horizon learning quality boundaries, and dimension-scoped memory-provider parity evidence.	`independent_outcome_cohort_review`, `task_scoped_causal_learning`, `memory_provider_parity_matrix`, `/api/operator/independent-learning-memory-parity`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and final-audit linkage.
19	#508 Batch CN: dense long-work operator debugging and recovery control	Stronger operator-control evidence beyond Batch CB/CH bounded receipts: bounded dense debugging, recovery, branch/compare, approval, audit, handoff, keyboard/accessibility, and independent usability/accessibility receipts for the named task matrix.	`long_work_debugging_recovery`, `operator_control_density`, `independent_operator_usability_accessibility`, `/api/operator/dense-operator-recovery-control`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and final-audit linkage.
20	#510 Batch CO: production marketplace security and package-network operations	Stronger marketplace evidence beyond Batch CA/CG bounded receipts: independent package-security review, hostile ecosystem tests, package-network incidents, publisher trust, vulnerability handling, rollback diagnostics, raw receipt paths, and operator notification while keeping production-secure marketplace claims blocked.	`independent_package_security_review`, `hostile_ecosystem_package_drills`, `package_network_incident_operations`, `publisher_trust_vulnerability_handling`, `marketplace_rollback_quarantine_diagnostics`, `/api/operator/production-marketplace-security`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
21	#511 Batch CP: browser computer-use safety receipts and parity boundary	Stronger browser/computer-use evidence beyond Batch BY/CH bounded receipts: safe-target task depth, login/session partitioning, credential isolation, site-specific recovery, provider reliability, independent usability evidence, and explicit full-browser-parity claim blocking.	`live_browser_task_depth`, `autonomous_browser_safety_controls`, `browser_session_partitioning_security`, `site_specific_recovery_drills`, `browser_provider_reliability_matrix`, `independent_browser_usability_review`, `/api/operator/safe-autonomous-browser-computer-use`, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
22	#512 Batch CQ: full parity claim lift and final critic audit	Completed bounded claim-lift gate after Batches CJ-CP: current-source competitor refresh, issue/Project/PR/test/docs reconciliation, exact claim-ledger permission, and independent Critic/Contrarian review.	Expanded final parity audit receipts, SCL-028 through SCL-033 claim-lift matrix, exact stronger-claim outcomes, Project/PR receipt, false-claim scan posture, source-refresh access caveats, and final critic proof suites plus aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
23	#522 Batch CR: post-CQ shipped-truth and board baseline reconciliation	Reconcile post-merge CQ truth across code, tests, operator receipts, docs, and board references before the next production-evidence train starts.	CQ modeled as Done with PR #521 merged, bounded proof-train wording currently allowed, broad claims still blocked, stale CQ wording removed.
24	#523 Batch CS: continuous durable orchestration and workflow SLO operations	Production-like continuous workflow operations beyond bounded orchestration receipts: rolling run windows, scheduler/provider health, crash/failover soak, replay authority, side-effect reconciliation, duplicate suppression, irreversible boundaries, and operator recovery controls.	`continuous_orchestration_slo_monitor`, `crash_failover_soak_v1`, `side_effect_reconciliation_v2`, `/api/operator/continuous-orchestration-slo`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-034 claim-ledger linkage.
25	#524 Batch CT: container-grade secure capability host and external security validation	Stronger secure capability-host validation beyond bounded secure-host receipts: capability-class isolation decision records, signed tool roots, credential broker and network-boundary checks, external review scope, remediation or waiver records, secret-egress drills, recovery authority, and explicit unsupported hardware-backed/runtime-isolation boundaries while keeping IronClaw-class and production-security claims blocked.	`container_grade_capability_isolation`, `external_security_validation_v1`, `secret_egress_certification_drill`, `/api/operator/container-grade-secure-host`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-035 claim-ledger linkage.
26	#525 Batch CU: broad reach, channel reliability, and voice-media field operations	Broader provider/channel field operations and voice/media field evidence beyond bounded reach receipts, with consent, revocation, abuse/rate-limit, degraded recovery, continuity IDs, safe redacted receipt metadata, bounded SLO/provider-failure/offline recovery, and explicit coverage gaps while keeping OpenClaw-class reach, voice parity, always-available, production-readiness, and full-parity claims blocked.	`broad_reach_field_operations`, `voice_media_quality_operations`, `always_available_reach_slo`, `/api/operator/broad-reach-field-ops`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-036 claim-ledger linkage.
27	#526 Batch CV: longitudinal guardian learning and memory-provider outcome operations	Longer-horizon learning and memory-provider outcome operations beyond bounded cohort and matrix receipts, with named baseline source/version/limitations, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, policy rollback, provider quarantine/reinstatement, delete/export propagation, and safe redacted receipt boundaries.	`longitudinal_guardian_outcome_study`, `named_baseline_memory_comparison`, `learning_safety_monitor_v2`, `/api/operator/longitudinal-guardian-outcomes`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-037 claim-ledger linkage.
28	#527 Batch CW: dense operator mission control and long-work debugging parity	Denser mission-control implementation and broader usability/recovery evidence beyond bounded operator-control receipts, with redacted population-study handles, named baseline pressure rows, receiver scope-renewal handoff, read-only replay/runbook policies, and explicit best-cockpit/solved-control claim blocking.	`operator_control_population_study`, `named_baseline_cockpit_comparison`, `long_work_debugging_slo`, `/api/operator/operator-control-population-study`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-038 claim-ledger linkage.
29	#528 Batch CX: production marketplace registry and package operations corpus	Real registry/corpus operations and continuous package-security monitoring beyond bounded marketplace receipts.	`marketplace_security_corpus_v1`, `continuous_vulnerability_monitoring`, `publisher_trust_operations`, `/api/operator/marketplace-security-corpus`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-039 claim-ledger linkage.
30	#529 Batch CY: managed browser computer-use production reliability and parity depth	Broader safe-target browser/computer-use depth, partition operations, and site recovery beyond bounded browser receipts.	`browser_task_breadth_matrix`, `browser_auth_partition_operations`, `site_drift_recovery_slo`, `/api/operator/browser-computer-use-parity-depth`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-040 claim-ledger linkage.
31	#530 Batch CZ: post-CQ production-evidence claim-readiness audit	Final post-CR-CY claim-readiness gate for static source receipts, issue/PR/operator snapshot reconciliation, live GitHub Project verification workflow requirements, claim-ledger permission, local false-claim scan, external GitHub PR/issue scan gate, and Critic/Contrarian review.	`post_cq_claim_ledger_reconciliation`, `reference_system_source_refresh_v2`, `false_completion_scan_v2`, `/api/operator/post-cq-claim-readiness`.
32	#540 Batch DA: production orchestration guarantees evidence program	Post-CZ production orchestration evidence beyond Batch CS bounded observation receipts: DA-specific persisted authority tables, scheduler/workflow/worker state, resumable steps, replay windows, recovery authority, failure-injection coverage, side-effect reconciliation, missing-live-evidence reporting, and operator-visible recovery/debug decisions.	`production_workflow_state_machine_v1`, `crash_proof_orchestration_fault_campaign`, `external_side_effect_reconciliation_v3`, `/api/operator/production-workflow-guarantees`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-043 claim-ledger linkage.
33	#541 Batch DB: secure isolation and hardware-backed host evidence program	Post-DA secure-host implementation evidence beyond Batch CT bounded validation receipts: covered-path capability policy hooks, runtime isolation profiles, tool/field/destination-scoped secret refs, MCP private-network/DNS endpoint blocking, process-runtime network-client marker denial, external review/certification-scope records, finding retest and waiver expiry, hostile runtime escape drills, and explicit hardware-backed substitute boundaries.	`runtime_isolation_implementation_v1`, `credential_broker_egress_enforcement_v1`, `external_security_certification_v1`, `hostile_runtime_escape_gauntlet_v1`, `/api/operator/certified-secure-host`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-044 claim-ledger linkage.
34	#542 Batch DC: always-available reach and voice-media parity evidence program	Selected-channel reach/media operational-campaign evidence beyond Batch CU field-operation/SLO receipts, with mobile/messaging/native/browser/web campaign windows, voice/media runtime quality, cross-surface continuity, degraded recovery metrics, and explicit coverage gaps while keeping OpenClaw-class reach, always-available, voice parity, production-readiness, and full-parity claims blocked.	`always_available_reach_operations_v1`, `voice_media_parity_runtime_v1`, `mobile_cross_surface_continuity_v1`, `reach_degraded_recovery_field_campaign`, `/api/operator/always-available-reach-media`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-045 claim-ledger linkage.
35	#543 Batch DD: guardian outcome and memory parity evidence program	Higher post-CZ guardian-outcome and memory-provider evidence beyond Batch CM/CV receipts, with predeclared multi-decision outcome protocols, independent evaluator metadata, adverse-event review, expanded provider parity matrix dimensions, causal thresholds, and pressure-only named baselines while keeping guardian superiority, memory superiority, full provider parity, named baseline wins, production-readiness, and full-parity claims blocked.	`generalized_guardian_outcome_study_v1`, `full_memory_provider_parity_matrix_v1`, `causal_learning_outcome_thresholds_v1`, `memory_baseline_comparison_v1`, `/api/operator/generalized-guardian-outcomes`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-046 claim-ledger linkage.
36	#544 Batch DE: operator mission-control and solved-control evidence program	Higher post-CZ operator-control certification evidence beyond Batch CW receipts, with full required-control coverage, click/keystroke/latency/recovery/effort telemetry, accessibility and keyboard-only paths, stale approval blocking, safe denial, confidence calibration, recovery correctness, pressure-only named baselines, and explicit formal-certification/best-cockpit/solved-control claim blocking.	`operator_control_certification_v1`, `mission_control_population_study_v2`, `long_work_recovery_slo_v2`, `operator_error_detectability_v1`, `/api/operator/operator-control-certification`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-047 claim-ledger linkage.
37	#545 Batch DF: marketplace and package-security evidence program	Higher post-CZ marketplace and third-party package-security evidence beyond Batch CX receipts, with larger live-corpus quality, gate-matrix enforcement, external review/certification-scope records, waiver/retest receipts, fail-closed lifecycle operations, hostile package lifecycle drills, and explicit production-secure/solved-security/full-marketplace-parity claim blocking.	`production_secure_marketplace_v1`, `third_party_package_security_certification_v1`, `marketplace_live_corpus_operations_v2`, `hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v1`, `/api/operator/production-secure-marketplace`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-048 claim-ledger linkage.
38	#546 Batch DG: browser and computer-use parity evidence program	Higher browser/computer-use parity evidence beyond Batch CY receipts, with provider execution caveats, blocked existing-session attachment, clipboard/private-data/network negative cases, hostile-browser drills, deterministic safe-target drift fixture recovery v2, partition certification-scope receipts, and explicit safe-automation/full-browser-parity claim blocking.	`safe_autonomous_browser_runtime_v1`, `full_browser_parity_matrix_v1`, `real_site_drift_recovery_v2`, `browser_session_partition_certification_v1`, `/api/operator/full-browser-parity`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-049 claim-ledger linkage.
39	#547 Batch DH: final production parity reconciliation and claim-boundary gate	Final bounded reconciliation for the DA-DG train, with manual current reference-system source-review receipts, seven-area production-readiness soak-readiness reconciliation, issue/PR/board reconciliation, stale PR closure evidence, false-completion scanning, exact claim-lift decisions, and explicit production-ready/full-parity/superiority claim blocking.	`production_readiness_soak_v1`, `final_full_parity_claim_lift_v1`, `reference_system_source_refresh_v3`, `false_completion_scan_v3`, `board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v3`, `/api/operator/final-production-parity`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-050 claim-ledger linkage.
40	#560 Batch DI: production orchestration hard-guarantee evidence program	Post-DH production orchestration hard-guarantee evidence beyond Batch DA bounded workflow-guarantee receipts, with durable queue/scheduler leases, worker failover, replay authority, distributed recovery operations, side-effect correctness v4, accelerated fixture soak receipts with missing-live-window markers, operator recovery controls, false-claim scans, and explicit exactly-once/crash-proof/solved-workflow claim blocking.	`production_orchestration_hard_guarantees_v1`, `distributed_workflow_recovery_operations_v1`, `external_side_effect_correctness_v4`, `scheduler_failover_soak_v1`, `orchestration_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/production-orchestration-hard-guarantees`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-051 claim-ledger linkage.
41	#558 Batch DJ: certification-track secure runtime isolation evidence program	Post-DI secure-runtime isolation evidence beyond Batch DB/CT/CK/CD bounded receipts, with cross-surface hostile chains, credential broker egress checks, runtime attestation matrices, operator recovery authority, safe redacted digests, and explicit secure/private-by-default, IronClaw-class, hardware-backed, and formal-certification claim blocking.	`production_grade_secure_capability_host_evidence_v1`, `secure_host_cross_surface_attack_chain_v1`, `credential_broker_egress_soak_v1`, `runtime_isolation_attestation_matrix_v1`, `secure_host_operator_recovery_authority_v1`, `secure_host_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/production-grade-secure-capability-host`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-052 claim-ledger linkage.
42	#557 Batch DK: always-available reach and voice/media operations evidence program	Post-DI reach/media operations evidence beyond Batch DC/CU/CL/CE bounded receipts, with multi-channel operational windows, provider incident response, offline/degraded recovery, cross-surface continuity, STT/TTS/media quality receipts, and explicit OpenClaw-class reach, always-available, voice/media parity, and complete-channel-coverage claim blocking.	`always_available_reach_live_ops_v1`, `voice_media_production_parity_candidate_v1`, `channel_incident_response_v1`, `cross_surface_reach_continuity_v2`, `reach_media_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/reach-voice-production-ops`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-053 claim-ledger linkage.
43	#559 Batch DL: guardian outcome and memory-provider validation field program	Post-DI guardian-learning and memory-provider field evidence beyond Batch DD/CV/CM/CF bounded receipts, with live field windows, behavior-change ablations, independent longitudinal adjudication, provider quarantine/reinstatement, rollback authority, and explicit solved-learning, memory-superiority, and live-human-outcome-superiority claim blocking.	`live_long_horizon_guardian_learning_field_study_v1`, `memory_behavior_change_ablation_v1`, `live_memory_provider_parity_operations_v1`, `independent_guardian_outcome_candidate_review_v1`, `longitudinal_learning_safety_monitor_v3`, `guardian_memory_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/live-guardian-memory-field-program`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and SCL-054 claim-ledger linkage.
44	#562 Batch DM: operator-control certification and tamper-evident audit evidence program	Adds bounded post-DI operator-control production-certification receipts beyond Batch DE/CW/CN bounded receipts, with long-work pressure controls, stale approval blocking, recovery correctness, operator takeover, authority-transfer boundaries, accessibility/population telemetry, audit digest linkage, mutation denial, replay/runbook boundaries, and explicit solved-control, best/world-class cockpit, tamper-proof-audit, and formal-certification claim blocking.	`operator_control_certification_v2`, `operator_control_live_population_v1`, `tamper_evident_audit_candidate_v1`, `authority_transfer_recovery_v1`, `operator_control_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/operator-control-production-certification`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and SCL-055 claim-ledger linkage.
45	#564 Batch DN: marketplace security certification-track operations evidence program	Post-DI marketplace/package-security operations evidence beyond Batch DF/CX/CO/CG bounded receipts, with provenance, signatures, SBOM/dependency evidence, scanner freshness, hostile lifecycle drills, publisher trust operations, rollback/quarantine/re-entry diagnostics, and explicit production-secure marketplace, solved package-security, and formal-certification claim blocking.	`marketplace_security_certification_track_v1`, `production_secure_marketplace_live_ops_v2`, `ecosystem_supply_chain_operations_v1`, `hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v2`, `publisher_trust_vulnerability_ops_v1`, `marketplace_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/marketplace-production-security`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-056 claim-ledger linkage.
46	#561 Batch DO: browser/computer-use production safety and parity-candidate operations evidence program	Post-DI browser/computer-use operations evidence beyond Batch DG/CY/CP/CH bounded receipts, with local/managed/remote-CDP and existing-session trust records, session/profile/credential/file/network/private-data boundaries, hostile-page fail-closed cases, real-site or safe-target recovery, provider degradation, and explicit safe-browser, safe-autonomous-computer-use, and full-browser-parity claim blocking.	`browser_computer_use_production_safety_v1`, `safe_browser_automation_live_ops_v1`, `credentialed_site_recovery_v1`, `browser_provider_parity_candidate_v1`, `browser_session_partition_attestation_v2`, `browser_false_claim_scan_v1`, `/api/operator/browser-computer-use-production`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and SCL-057 claim-ledger linkage.
47	#563 Batch DP: final post-DI-DO production-readiness and parity/exceedance release gate	Final release gate after #560, #558, #557, #559, #562, #564, and #561 are closed and board-reconciled, with current-source Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw refresh, issue/PR/test/docs/operator/API/claim-ledger reconciliation, false-completion scanning, and independent Critic/Contrarian no-block review.	`full_parity_claim_lift_audit_v1`, `production_readiness_reconciliation_v2`, `reference_system_source_refresh_v4`, `post_di_do_board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v1`, `false_completion_scan_v4`, `final_critic_contrarian_no_block_v1`, `/api/operator/full-parity-release-gate`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and exact claim-ledger permission.
48	#573 Batch DQ: post-DP durable orchestration gap-closure implementation program	Real implementation gap closure beyond bounded orchestration receipts, covering multi-session state, multi-agent handoff, scheduler interruption, crash/retry recovery, idempotency, side-effect reconciliation, and guardian-aware operator recovery.	New or extended durable orchestration, handoff recovery, crash/failover restart, side-effect reconciliation, unsafe-resume blocking, duplicate-side-effect suppression, operator receipt, and false-claim scan gates.
49	#574 Batch DR: post-DP secure capability-host gap-closure implementation program	Real secure-host gap closure beyond bounded certification-track receipts, covering runtime profile selection, deny-by-default egress, scoped credentials, package/browser/session boundaries, hostile chains, quarantine, revocation, and recovery authority.	Runtime isolation, credential broker egress, hostile cross-surface chain, revocation/recovery authority, redaction, quarantine, denial receipt, and false-claim scan gates.
50	#575 Batch DS: post-DP reach and channel gap-closure implementation program	Real reach/channel gap closure beyond bounded reach/voice operations receipts, covering selected `native_notification` and `websocket` runtime surfaces, pairing, revocation, consent, abuse/rate limits, provider outage, offline/degraded recovery, guardian continuity, voice/media privacy fallback, staged mobile/messaging/voice gaps, and blocked claims.	Selected native-notification/websocket operation, degraded recovery, cross-surface continuity, privacy fallback, pairing/revocation, safe redacted receipts, staged gap receipts, and false-claim scan gates.
51	#576 Batch DT: post-DP guardian learning and memory gap-closure implementation program	Real guardian learning and memory gap closure beyond bounded field-study/provider receipts, covering consented long-horizon cohorts, behavior-change ablations, reversible learning, rollback, stale evidence, provider quarantine, delete/export propagation, and safety monitoring.	`post_dp_guardian_learning_memory_gap_closure_v1`, `long_horizon_learning_quality_v2`, `memory_behavior_ablation_v2`, `memory_provider_operation_v2`, `learning_safety_regression_v2`, `guardian_memory_false_claim_scan_v2`, `/api/operator/post-dp-guardian-learning-memory-gap-closure`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and SCL-062 claim-ledger linkage.
52	#577 Batch DU: post-DP operator debugging and recovery-control gap-closure implementation program	Real operator-control gap closure beyond bounded certification receipts, covering inspect/pause/resume/retry/repair/branch/compare/revoke/quarantine/handoff/rollback/audit/search/replay/runbook flows, dense long-work diagnosis, authority transfer, and accessibility receipt coverage.	`post_dp_operator_debugging_recovery_control_v1`, `dense_long_work_debugging_v2`, `operator_recovery_slo_v3`, `operator_effort_reduction_v2`, `authority_transfer_integrity_v2`, `operator_audit_accessibility_v2`, `operator_control_false_claim_scan_v2`, `/api/operator/post-dp-operator-debugging-recovery-control`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-063 claim-ledger linkage.
53	#578 Batch DV: post-DP capability marketplace lifecycle gap-closure implementation program	Real marketplace lifecycle/security gap closure beyond bounded certification-track receipts, covering install/update/downgrade/disable/rollback/quarantine/re-entry, provenance, signatures, publisher trust, SBOM/dependency evidence, vulnerability policy, compatibility, permissions, and runtime-boundary diagnostics.	`post_dp_capability_marketplace_lifecycle_gap_closure_v1`, `marketplace_lifecycle_operations_v3`, `package_review_waiver_policy_v2`, `marketplace_vulnerability_monitoring_v2`, `hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v3`, `marketplace_rollback_quarantine_diagnostics_v2`, `marketplace_secure_host_audit_integration_v1`, `marketplace_lifecycle_false_claim_scan_v2`, `/api/operator/post-dp-marketplace-lifecycle-gap-closure`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-064 claim-ledger linkage.
54	#579 Batch DW: post-DP browser/computer-use reliability gap-closure implementation program	Bounded post-DP browser/computer-use reliability gap closure beyond DO production-safety receipts, covering selected provider modes, operator-visible degradation, no silent fallback, credentialed test-account recovery, session/profile/cookie/credential/file/network/private-data partitions under recovery pressure, site drift, hostile-page fail-closed behavior, artifact provenance, and non-duplication over CH/CP/CY/DG/DO/DP.	`post_dp_browser_computer_use_reliability_v1`, `browser_live_provider_reliability_v2`, `browser_session_boundary_enforcement_v3`, `browser_credentialed_recovery_v2`, `browser_site_drift_recovery_v3`, `browser_hostile_page_safety_v2`, `browser_provider_degradation_v2`, `browser_computer_use_false_claim_scan_v2`, `/api/operator/post-dp-browser-computer-use-reliability`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-065 claim-ledger linkage.
55	#580 Batch DX: post-DQ-DW claim-readiness and release gate	Final release gate after DQ-DW close with board reconciliation, docs/code/API/operator receipt reconciliation, current-source Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw refresh, X article access caveat, claim-ledger permission, false-completion scan, and independent Critic/Contrarian no-block review.	`post_dq_dw_board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v1`, `post_dq_dw_claim_ledger_reconciliation_v1`, `reference_system_source_refresh_v5`, `false_completion_scan_v5`, `post_dq_dw_critic_contrarian_no_block_v1`, `/api/operator/post-dq-dw-claim-readiness`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-066 claim-ledger linkage.
56	#590 Batch DY: post-DX live durable orchestration parity proof	Stronger post-DX orchestration evidence beyond DQ/DX, covering recorded-live and accelerated orchestration windows, scheduler/provider jitter, crash/restart/failover drills, replay authority, duplicate suppression, side-effect reconciliation, multi-agent handoff durability, operator recovery controls, residual-risk markers, and false-claim scans.	`post_dx_live_durable_orchestration_v1`, `recorded_live_orchestration_window_v1`, `crash_restart_failover_drill_v3`, `multi_agent_handoff_durability_v2`, `side_effect_reconciliation_v6`, `operator_recovery_control_v4`, `orchestration_false_claim_scan_v3`, `/api/operator/post-dx-live-durable-orchestration`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-067 claim-ledger linkage.
57	#593 Batch DZ: post-DX formal secure runtime isolation and trust certification proof	Stronger post-DX secure-runtime evidence beyond DB/DJ/DR, covering runtime-attestation evidence, credential-broker egress enforcement, hostile-chain containment, external review/certification-track records, operator recovery authority, unsupported hardware-backed and TEE/CVM/Wasm/container markers, and false-claim scans.	`post_dx_formal_secure_runtime_isolation_v1`, `runtime_isolation_attestation_evidence_v2`, `credential_broker_egress_enforcement_v3`, `hostile_chain_containment_v4`, `external_security_review_certification_track_v2`, `secure_runtime_recovery_authority_v3`, `secure_runtime_false_claim_scan_v3`, `/api/operator/post-dx-formal-secure-runtime-isolation`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-068 claim-ledger linkage.
58	#592 Batch EA: post-DX always-available reach and voice/media parity proof	Stronger post-DX reach/voice-media evidence beyond DK/DS, covering selected and candidate multi-channel reliability, provider identity, consent, pairing, revocation, delivery metrics, rate limits, abuse handling, degraded/offline recovery, voice/media quality and latency gates, cross-surface continuity, coverage gaps, and false-claim scans.	`post_dx_reach_voice_media_parity_proof_v1`, `multi_channel_reach_reliability_v3`, `voice_media_quality_latency_v3`, `reach_abuse_recovery_v3`, `cross_surface_reach_continuity_v3`, `reach_voice_media_false_claim_scan_v3`, `/api/operator/post-dx-reach-voice-media-parity-proof`, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, blocked claims, and SCL-069 claim-ledger linkage.
59	#595 Batch EE: browser/computer-use live reliability and recovery controls	User-facing browser/computer-use control gap beyond DW reliability receipts, covering owner-scoped sessions, provider degradation, no-silent-fallback replay acknowledgement, partition reset, quarantine/recovery, boundary-decision visibility, redacted provenance, and cockpit controls.	`/api/browser/sessions`, `/api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/snapshot`, `/api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/control`, `/api/operator/browser-computer-use-control`, cockpit Browser computer-use live controls, owner-scope tests, degraded fallback replay tests, quarantine/recovery tests, redacted provenance tests, blocked claims, and SCL-070 claim-ledger linkage.

Blocked claim boundary for the train: no issue or PR may claim full parity, superiority, production readiness, secure/private by default, IronClaw-class secure execution, solved durable workflows, exactly-once or crash-proof orchestration, broad OpenClaw-class reach, voice/multimodal parity, production-secure marketplace, safe autonomous browser/computer-use, full browser parity, best/world-class cockpit, solved operator control, or exceeded reference systems unless the claim ledger permits the exact wording after merged proof.

Batch BV readiness proof is intentionally a contract layer. It proves that later batches have named proof paths, validation classes, operator receipt targets, negative-case requirements, review-role requirements, duplicate-scope guardrails, Project-field requirements, current-source requirements for competitor-dependent claims, receipt-schema fields, and blocked claim wording. It does not prove that the later production-grade implementations are complete.

Batch BW is the first implementation proof gate after readiness. It makes the secure-host hardening receipts operator-visible through /api/operator/secure-capability-host-hardening and aggregate benchmark proof, but the claim boundary remains unchanged: no broad secure/private-by-default, production-ready, IronClaw-class secure execution, TEE/Wasm/container isolation, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording is allowed without later proof and claim-ledger permission.

Batch BX extends durable workflow proof beyond the v1 state kernel with operator-visible v2 orchestration receipts for leases, idempotent transitions, trigger dedupe, unsafe-resume blocks, and delegated-artifact adoption gates. It remains bounded proof, not LangGraph-class durability, exactly-once external scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, or solved workflow parity.

Batch BY extends reach, browser, and voice/media proof beyond the earlier canary and governance floors. It makes paired external messaging, browser reliability, and guarded voice/media runtime receipts operator-visible through /api/operator/production-reach-browser-voice and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking broad reach, complete channel coverage, voice parity, multimodal parity, safe browser automation, always-available operation, and full browser parity claims.

Batch BZ extends guardian learning and memory-provider proof beyond deterministic arbitration/provider-quality floors. It makes typed intervention outcome cohorts, false-positive and false-negative learning receipts, stale-evidence decay, provider usefulness/degradation/quarantine, canonical memory precedence, advisory writeback, deletion/export receipts, and provider usefulness regressions operator-visible through /api/operator/live-guardian-learning-quality and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking guardian intelligence superiority, solved long-term learning, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, live human-outcome superiority, full production parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CA extends ecosystem proof beyond M9 local governance and governed capability-pack hardening. It makes lifecycle mutation receipts, permission/risk deltas, cross-family package coverage, staged rollout, failed-update rollback, quarantine re-entry review, diagnostics, and package-count claim blocking operator-visible through /api/operator/marketplace-lifecycle-maturity and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production-secure marketplace, third-party package security solved, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, full production parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CB integrates the production parity train into one operator-control and verification surface. It makes long-work control receipts, prior train PR/suite/operator-surface receipts, residual risks, Project-state receipts, blocked claims, and final critic/audit requirements visible through /api/operator/production-operator-control-parity and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking best-cockpit, solved-operator-control, full parity, production readiness, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CC extends durable-orchestration truth beyond Batch BX by adding recorded-live provider and crash-study receipts. It makes external scheduler identity, evidence mode, replay windows, idempotency keys, side-effect boundaries, delivery semantics, injected failure studies, duplicate-replay suppression, resume authority, and operator recovery controls visible through /api/operator/live-external-orchestration and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking exactly-once production scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, a full distributed workflow engine, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CD extends secure-host truth beyond Batch BW by adding production-isolation and security-incident receipts. It makes worker-root boundaries, browser-profile partitioning, connector credential proxying, extension quarantine, workflow trust guards, privileged-path red-team blocks, replayable incident recovery, credential rotation, operator notification, and operator recovery controls visible through /api/operator/production-isolation-hardening and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking secure/private-by-default execution, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, full host/container/TEE/CVM/Wasm isolation, safe autonomous computer use, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CE extends reach/media truth beyond Batch BY by adding live/recorded-live channel and provider receipts. It makes mobile push, external messaging, STT, TTS, media-analysis, cross-surface thread continuity, memory continuity, approval survival, provider failure, rate limit, abuse handling, revocation, and degraded recovery receipts visible through /api/operator/live-reach-media-proof and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking broad reach, complete channel coverage, OpenClaw-class reach, voice parity, multimodal parity, production STT/TTS solved, always-available operation, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CF extends guardian-learning truth beyond Batch BZ by adding recorded-live study and causal-attribution receipts. It makes consent-aware anonymized human-outcome cohorts, correction/harm/follow-through evidence, residual bias and coverage limitations, counterfactual causal attribution, reversible learning changes, stale-evidence decay, provider usefulness deltas, privacy regression monitoring, and quarantine receipts visible through /api/operator/live-human-outcome-learning-proof and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking guardian intelligence superiority, solved live learning, live human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CG extends marketplace truth beyond Batch CA by adding recorded-live third-party attestation and incident-operation receipts. It makes package provenance, signatures, publisher verification, compatibility, dependency and vulnerability attestation, install/update/downgrade/rollback/quarantine/re-entry operations, failed-update diagnostics, publisher identity/key-rotation/review freshness, trust explanations, and package-count claim blocking visible through /api/operator/live-marketplace-attestation-proof and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production-secure marketplace, third-party package security solved, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CH extends browser/computer-use and cockpit-control truth beyond Batch BY and Batch CB by adding provider-attestation, multi-operator usability, and recovery-drill receipts. It makes local, managed-remote, and remote-CDP provider identity, evidence mode, session partitioning, credential boundaries, download/upload boundaries, provider degradation, inspect/recover/approval/handoff/audit/keyboard/accessibility/error-rate metrics, and fail-closed provider crash/page drift/credential/download-upload recovery visible through /api/operator/browser-provider-usability-proof and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking safe browser automation, full browser parity, best cockpit, world-class cockpit, solved operator control, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CI closes the current production parity train as an audit and wording-governance gate, not as a blanket product-completion claim. It makes current Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw source receipts, pressure-axis mapping, verified merged PR receipts for Batches BV-CH, Project-field requirements, claim-ledger reconciliation, residual gaps, and accepted Critic/Contrarian dispositions visible through /api/operator/final-parity-readiness-report and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking full parity, reference-system exceedance, production-ready, secure/private-by-default, OpenClaw-class reach, IronClaw-class secure execution, safe browser automation, full browser parity, production-secure marketplace, and guardian-intelligence superiority wording.

Batch CJ narrows the orchestration residual called out by Batch CI. It makes provider SLA windows, jitter budgets, replay windows, idempotency scopes, side-effect boundaries, failure-injection methods, duplicate side-effect reconciliation, operator recovery controls, blocked claims, and final-audit linkage visible through /api/operator/production-sla-orchestration and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, a full distributed workflow engine, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CS narrows the orchestration-operations residual beyond Batch CJ without lifting the strongest workflow claims. It makes deterministic runtime observation state, rolling monitor windows, scheduler/provider health, retry and jitter budgets, crash/failover soak receipts, replay authority, idempotency keys, duplicate suppression, irreversible side-effect boundaries, manual recovery state, operator controls, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/continuous-orchestration-slo and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, a full distributed workflow engine, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CK narrows the independent security residual called out by Batch CI. It makes reviewer scope, finding remediation, isolation evidence matrices, live hostile drill receipts, operator recovery authority, blocked claims, and final-audit linkage visible through /api/operator/independent-secure-host-review and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking secure/private-by-default execution, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, hardware-backed/container-grade isolation implementation, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CT narrows the container-grade secure-host validation residual beyond Batch CK. It makes capability-class isolation decision records, signed tool roots, credential broker and network-boundary checks, external review scope, finding remediation or waiver records, secret-egress certification drills, recovery authority, unsupported hardware-backed/runtime-isolation boundaries, blocked claims, and final-audit linkage visible through /api/operator/container-grade-secure-host and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking secure/private-by-default execution, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, hardware-backed/TEE/CVM/Wasm/container isolation implementation, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CL narrows the reach/media residual called out by Batch CI and Batch CE. It makes provider-window behavior, rate limits, abuse handling, degraded recovery, coverage-gap claim boundaries, STT/TTS/media quality and latency gates, correction/deletion privacy boundaries, provider-regression fallback, notification approval handoff, mobile action continuity, thread/memory recovery, offline recovery, and revocation fail-closed behavior visible through /api/operator/production-reach-voice-mobile and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, voice parity, multimodal parity, always-available operation, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CU narrows the reach/media field-operation residual beyond Batch CL. It makes provider/channel field matrices, consent and revocation fail-closed checks, rate-limit and abuse drills, degraded recovery, cross-surface continuity IDs, metadata-only redacted receipt boundaries, voice/media quality and latency gates, correction/deletion/privacy controls, bounded reach-SLO windows, provider-failure and offline recovery, operator recovery actions, coverage gaps, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/broad-reach-field-ops and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, voice parity, multimodal parity, always-available operation, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch DC narrows the reach/media operational-campaign residual beyond Batch CU. It makes selected mobile, messaging, native, browser, and web campaign receipts, pairing/revocation, rate-limit and abuse recovery, 14-day equivalent degraded-recovery windows, STT/TTS/voice/media latency and quality receipts, correction/deletion/privacy controls, provider-regression fallback, cross-surface continuity, false and missed delivery metrics, operator repair actions, redacted receipt boundaries, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/always-available-reach-media and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice/media parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch DD narrows the generalized guardian-outcome and memory-provider parity residual beyond Batch CM/CV. It makes predeclared act/defer/bundle/clarify/approval/stay-silent/recovery/follow-through outcome protocols, independent evaluator metadata, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, fairness and adverse-event review, expanded canonical/advisory provider matrices, privacy/delete/export/stale-recall/quarantine/reinstatement receipts, counterfactual causal thresholds, rollback authority, current-source-limited named baselines, redacted receipt boundaries, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/generalized-guardian-outcomes and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking guardian intelligence superiority, solved live/long-term learning, live-human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, named baseline wins, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CM narrows the guardian-learning and memory-provider residual called out by Batch CI and Batch CF. It makes independent evaluator metadata, consent/anonymization, sample and power rationale, adverse-event review, bounded outcome claims, task-scoped counterfactual causal receipts, confounder boundaries, rollback authority, canonical/advisory memory-provider comparison, provider privacy regressions, quarantine, delete/export receipts, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/independent-learning-memory-parity and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking guardian intelligence superiority, solved live learning, generalized live human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CV narrows the longitudinal learning and memory-provider operations residual beyond Batch CM. It makes 60-plus day outcome windows, task families, named baseline source/version/limitations, pressure-only baseline comparison, independent evaluator protocol, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, adverse-event review, reversible learning-policy deltas, rollback authority, canonical/advisory provider comparison, stale-behavior blocking, privacy-regression quarantine, delete/export propagation, provider reinstatement review, safe redacted receipts, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/longitudinal-guardian-outcomes and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking guardian intelligence superiority, solved live learning, solved long-term learning, live human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, named baseline wins, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CW narrows the operator-control residual beyond Batch CN. It makes population-study receipts, named cockpit baseline pressure rows, long-work debugging SLOs, searchable timeline/log-diff/replay/runbook/handoff surfaces, safe redacted receipt handles, receiver scope-renewal handoff, and read-only replay/runbook authority boundaries visible through /api/operator/operator-control-population-study and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking best/world-class cockpit, solved operator control, approval-transfer, tamper-proof audit, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CO narrows the marketplace-security residual called out by Batch CI and Batch CG. It makes independent reviewer metadata, package digest/signature/key trust, SBOM/dependency graph digests, vulnerability source/database freshness, severity/remediation/waiver policy, hostile package drills, package-network private/SSRF/secret/workspace denial decisions, rollback snapshots, quarantine/re-entry state, operator notification, and raw receipt paths visible through /api/operator/production-marketplace-security and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, ecosystem superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CX narrows the marketplace registry/corpus operations residual beyond Batch CO. It makes package-family corpus rows, provenance, signatures, publisher-key state, SBOM/dependency graph digests, compatibility, review state, scanner-source freshness, waiver expiry, remediation SLA, critical/high denial decisions, install/update/downgrade/rollback/quarantine/re-entry diagnostics, package-network/private/redirect/DNS/secret/workspace denial receipts, and metadata-only safe receipt handles visible through /api/operator/marketplace-security-corpus and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch DF narrows the marketplace/package-security residual beyond Batch CX. It makes production gate receipts, third-party package-security review/certification-scope rows, larger live corpus v2 package quality, lifecycle install/update/downgrade/disable/rollback/review/diagnostic/quarantine/re-entry flows, hostile private-network/SSRF/DNS/secret/workspace/dependency-confusion/rollback/quarantine-bypass/malicious-update drills, redacted safe handles, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/production-secure-marketplace and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, formal package-security certification, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system claims.

Batch CP narrows the browser/computer-use residual called out by Batch CI and Batch CH. It makes safe-target task-depth receipt evidence, autonomous safety-control receipts, browser session partitioning, credential/cookie/profile/download/upload/network boundaries, site-specific recovery drills, provider reliability, independent usability summaries, redacted receipt locations with evidence-body digests, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility visible through /api/operator/safe-autonomous-browser-computer-use, while still blocking blanket safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch CY narrows the browser/computer-use depth residual beyond Batch CP. It makes safe-target task breadth, provider identity, reliability windows, auth/session partition operations, profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/network boundaries, dangerous-action blocking, site-drift recovery SLOs, independent depth usability receipts, and prior CP safety-boundary linkage visible through /api/operator/browser-computer-use-parity-depth and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking blanket safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DG narrows the browser/computer-use residual beyond Batch CY. It makes safe-target runtime tasks, provider execution caveats, blocked existing-session attachment, profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/clipboard/network/private-data boundary matrices, deterministic safe-target drift fixture recovery v2, hostile-browser negative cases, partition certification-scope receipts, redacted safe receipts, and blocked claims visible through /api/operator/full-browser-parity and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking blanket safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DH closes the current DA-DG train as a reconciliation and claim-boundary gate, not as a product-wide completion claim. It makes manual current Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw source-review receipts, DA-DG issue/PR/board reconciliation, seven-area production-readiness soak-readiness reconciliation receipts, exact SCL-043 through SCL-050 claim-lift decisions, stale PR closure evidence, local and external false-completion scan receipts, and Critic/Contrarian dispositions visible through /api/operator/final-production-parity and aggregate benchmark proof, while still blocking production readiness, full parity, superiority, secure/private-by-default execution, OpenClaw-class reach, IronClaw-class secure execution, solved operator control, solved learning, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DI narrows the orchestration hard-guarantee residual beyond Batch DA without lifting stronger claims. It makes durable queue/scheduler lease receipts, worker failover, replay authority, distributed recovery operations, side-effect correctness v4, accelerated fixture soak receipts with missing-live-window markers, operator recovery controls, false-claim scans, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility available through /api/operator/production-orchestration-hard-guarantees, while still blocking unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, continuous live-soak completion, solved durable workflows, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DJ narrows the secure-runtime residual beyond Batch DB/CT/CK/CD without lifting stronger claims. It makes production-grade secure-host surface matrices, cross-surface hostile-chain receipts, credential-broker egress soak fixtures, runtime-attestation matrices, operator recovery authority, false-claim scan receipts, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility available through /api/operator/production-grade-secure-capability-host, while still blocking secure/private-by-default execution, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, hardware-backed isolation, TEE/CVM/Wasm/container runtime-isolation, formal security certification, safe autonomous computer use, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DR narrows the post-DP secure capability-host implementation residual beyond Batch DJ without lifting stronger claims. It makes explicit runtime profile selection, deny-by-default credential egress, scoped credential refs, hostile cross-surface quarantine, operator-owned recovery authority, safe redacted receipts, false-claim scans, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility available through /api/operator/post-dp-secure-capability-host, while still blocking secure/private-by-default execution, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, hardware-backed isolation, TEE/CVM/Wasm/container runtime-isolation, formal security certification, safe autonomous computer use, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DK narrows the reach/voice production-operations residual beyond Batch DC/CU/CL/CE through always_available_reach_live_ops_v1, voice_media_production_parity_candidate_v1, channel_incident_response_v1, cross_surface_reach_continuity_v2, reach_media_false_claim_scan_v1, and /api/operator/reach-voice-production-ops. It exposes selected live/degraded operational windows across mobile, messaging, native, browser, and web surfaces; provider identity; consent, pairing, and revocation receipts; rate-limit and abuse handling; provider outage/fallback drills; offline recovery; false/missed delivery metrics; operator repair actions; STT/TTS/voice/media quality and latency candidates; correction/deletion/privacy controls; cross-surface thread, memory, approval, notification, and operator-handoff continuity; redacted receipt handles; aggregate benchmark-proof visibility; and blocked claims. It does not permit OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice/media parity, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DS narrows the post-DP reach/channel residual without turning catalog metadata into runtime truth. It makes the currently proven selected runtime surfaces, native_notification and websocket, carry consent, pairing, revocation, provider identity, route health, degraded recovery, offline fallback, operator repair, guardian-aware timing/restraint continuity, thread/memory/approval continuity, voice/media privacy fallback, staged channel-gap declarations, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and false-claim scans through /api/operator/post-dp-reach-channel-gap-closure. It does not claim mobile push, Slack/Telegram-style connectors, or voice/media surfaces are production runtime transports unless later batches provide live transport proof; OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice/media parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording remain blocked unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DL narrows the guardian-learning and memory-provider field-validation residual beyond Batch DD/CV/CM/CF through live_long_horizon_guardian_learning_field_study_v1, memory_behavior_change_ablation_v1, live_memory_provider_parity_operations_v1, independent_guardian_outcome_candidate_review_v1, longitudinal_learning_safety_monitor_v3, guardian_memory_false_claim_scan_v1, and /api/operator/live-guardian-memory-field-program. It exposes pre-registered field windows, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, fixture-vs-live markers, memory-enabled behavior changes against memory-disabled or memory-limited counterfactuals, canonical/advisory/degraded/stale/conflicting/privacy-limited provider operations, delete/export propagation, quarantine, reinstatement, independent longitudinal review, learning safety negative cases, false-claim scan receipts, redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims. It does not permit guardian intelligence superiority, solved learning, live-human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DT narrows the post-DP guardian learning and memory implementation residual without turning field-study receipts into solved learning or memory-superiority claims. It makes consented long-horizon cohorts, withdrawal/anonymization/adverse-review receipts, memory-enabled versus memory-limited decision ablations, reversible learning deltas, stale-evidence decay, rollback authority, provider quarantine/reinstatement, delete/export propagation, learning-safety regressions, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and false-claim scans available through /api/operator/post-dp-guardian-learning-memory-gap-closure. It still blocks guardian intelligence superiority, solved live or long-term learning, live-human-outcome superiority, generalized outcome superiority, memory superiority, best-in-class memory, full memory-provider parity, named baseline wins, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DM narrows the operator-control and audit-evidence residual beyond Batch DE/CW/CN through operator_control_certification_v2, operator_control_live_population_v1, tamper_evident_audit_candidate_v1, authority_transfer_recovery_v1, operator_control_false_claim_scan_v1, and /api/operator/operator-control-production-certification. It exposes required dense long-work controls, stale-approval blocking, safe denial, recovery correctness, operator takeover, recorded-live plus fixture population telemetry, keyboard/accessibility floors, digest-linked tamper-evident audit candidate receipts, unauthorized mutation denial, authority-transfer scope renewal, replay/runbook boundaries, false-claim scan receipts, redacted safe receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims. It does not permit solved operator control, best/world-class cockpit, approval-transfer solved, tamper-proof audit, formal certification, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DU narrows the post-DP operator debugging and recovery-control residual beyond Batch DM through post_dp_operator_debugging_recovery_control_v1, dense_long_work_debugging_v2, operator_recovery_slo_v3, operator_effort_reduction_v2, authority_transfer_integrity_v2, operator_audit_accessibility_v2, operator_control_false_claim_scan_v2, and /api/operator/post-dp-operator-debugging-recovery-control. It exposes root-cause, affected-artifact, branch-compare, recovery-option, stale-approval, unsafe-denial, effort, authority-transfer, rollback/quarantine/revoke, keyboard/accessibility, digest-linked audit, redacted safe receipt, and real claim-scan command evidence through aggregate benchmark proof. It does not permit solved operator control, best/world-class cockpit, approval-transfer solved, tamper-proof audit, formal certification, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DN narrows the marketplace/package-security residual beyond Batch DF/CX/CO/CG through marketplace_security_certification_track_v1, production_secure_marketplace_live_ops_v2, ecosystem_supply_chain_operations_v1, hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v2, publisher_trust_vulnerability_ops_v1, marketplace_false_claim_scan_v1, and /api/operator/marketplace-production-security. It exposes certification-track review scope, finding/retest/waiver expiry, provenance/signature/publisher-key/SBOM/dependency evidence, computed scanner freshness, install/update/downgrade/rollback/quarantine/re-entry operations, hostile lifecycle v2 network/secret/workspace/rollback/quarantine denials, publisher trust and vulnerability operations, capability-host permission and audit boundaries, redacted safe receipt handles, false-claim scan receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims. It does not permit production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, formal package-security certification, ecosystem superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DO narrows the browser/computer-use residual beyond Batch DG/CY/CP/CH through browser_computer_use_production_safety_v1, safe_browser_automation_live_ops_v1, credentialed_site_recovery_v1, browser_provider_parity_candidate_v1, browser_session_partition_attestation_v2, browser_false_claim_scan_v1, and /api/operator/browser-computer-use-production. It exposes provider identity and support states, session/profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/clipboard/network/private-data boundaries, hostile-page fail-closed cases, dangerous-action default blocks, recorded-live safe-target operations, credentialed test-account recovery, provider degradation, existing-session blocks, redacted safe receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, false-claim scans, and blocked claims. It does not permit safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer use, OpenClaw-class browser reach, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch DW narrows the browser/computer-use residual beyond Batch DO without duplicating CH/CP/CY/DG/DO/DP. It adds post_dp_browser_computer_use_reliability_v1, browser_live_provider_reliability_v2, browser_session_boundary_enforcement_v3, browser_credentialed_recovery_v2, browser_site_drift_recovery_v3, browser_hostile_page_safety_v2, browser_provider_degradation_v2, browser_computer_use_false_claim_scan_v2, and /api/operator/post-dp-browser-computer-use-reliability. It exposes a predecessor delta matrix, selected provider identity/degradation/no-silent-fallback receipts, session/profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/clipboard/network/private-data boundary receipts under recovery pressure, credentialed test-account recovery, site-drift authority preservation, hostile-page and dangerous-action fail-closed receipts, artifact provenance, negative proof validators, redacted safe receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, false-claim scans, and blocked claims. It does not permit safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer use, OpenClaw-class browser reach, full browser parity, arbitrary credentialed browsing safety, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

Batch EE moves the browser/computer-use residual from receipt-only operator evidence into live reliability controls. It exposes owner-scoped browser sessions, provider degradation, no-silent-fallback replay acknowledgement, partition revisions and reset, boundary decisions, redacted artifact provenance, quarantine/recover/reset/replay/close controls, and cockpit inspection through /api/browser/sessions, /api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/snapshot, /api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/control, and /api/operator/browser-computer-use-control. It remains bounded live control, not safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer use, OpenClaw-class browser reach, full browser parity, arbitrary credentialed browsing safety, production readiness, full parity, or exceeded-reference-system wording unless the claim ledger permits exact wording.

The post-DP implementation gap-closure train is represented in GitHub under parent #475 by DQ-DX issues #573-#580. Those issues and the Project board are the execution layer; this roadmap records the historical proof sequence and claim boundaries. DQ-DX are closed with Status=Done, PR=Merged, and Code Review=Passed in the Project, and DX remains bounded to exact SCL-066 release-gate wording. The post-DX train under #590-#597 now has DY, DZ, EA, EB, EC, ED, and EE closed through PRs #599-#605. Batch EF under #594 is the final post-DX claim-lift gate and permits only exact SCL-072 bounded final-gate wording after merge. Post-EF work must not extend this proof sequence by default; it must rescope into feature-first batches unless it is the final claim-readiness pass after feature parity is implemented.

Batch CQ closed by merged PR #521 and permits only this exact bounded wording: "Seraph has completed a board-backed parity proof train and final claim-lift audit with bounded receipts." Broad full parity, production readiness, secure/private-by-default, OpenClaw-class, IronClaw-class, safe-browser, full-browser-parity, marketplace, superiority, and reference-system-exceeded wording remains blocked.

The post-CQ train starts with Batch CR because code, tests, docs, and operator receipts must agree on the merged CQ state before stronger production-evidence batches can begin. Batches CS-CY are not repeats of #505-#512; each raises the evidence threshold from bounded receipts to production-like operational implementation and field evidence. Batch CZ is the final post-CQ gate for static source receipts, CR-CY issue/PR/operator snapshot reconciliation, live GitHub Project verification workflow requirements, local false-completion scanning, external GitHub PR/issue scan requirements, and claim-ledger permission; it permits only exact SCL-041 bounded wording unless a later ledger row allows stronger language.

Roadmap Phases

Phase	Batch	Implementation goal	Proof gate	Dependency rule	Issue anchors
0	Board, proof, and claim normalization	Keep execution state, parent linkage, review state, proof gates, and claim wording current before new readiness claims.	Project receipt plus claim-ledger review.	Must precede any new public parity or targeted exceedance wording.	#468, #436
1	Secure execution host v1	Privileged paths fail closed across browser credentials, cookies, workspace escape, providers, connectors, delegation, shell, workflow replay, filesystem, background process, and secret egress.	`secure_capability_host` plus `trust_boundary_and_safety_receipts`, with cockpit-readable adversarial receipts.	Must precede high-risk reach, marketplace expansion, and stronger browser/computer-use claims.	historical #428, #435, #455
2	Live long-horizon eval replay v1	Add live-ish fake providers, replay fixtures, failure taxonomy, CI receipts, and operator evidence across memory, workflow, reach, security, cockpit, and intervention paths.	Cross-surface replay harness with deterministic and live-ish receipts.	Feeds every later quality claim; no broad parity claim should skip it.	#457, PR #458
3	Cockpit operator efficiency benchmark	Measure inspect, approve, deny, pause, resume, retry, repair, branch, compare, revoke, audit, confidence, and error detectability on real operator tasks.	M7 benchmark over workflow, memory, trust, and reach scenarios, not synthetic UI density alone.	Needs replay receipts so the same operator tasks can be re-run and compared.	#439, PR #459
4	Memory provider quality gate	External memory evidence declares provenance, confidence, privacy boundary, freshness, conflict behavior, usefulness, suppression, and canonical writeback rules.	`guardian_memory_quality` plus provider-quality receipts showing behavior change, suppression, or refusal.	Must land before memory-provider breadth is treated as a guardian advantage.	#441, PR #460
5	Workflow endurance canary	Multi-session work proves checkpoint, branch, interruption, delegated ownership, failure injection, recovery, artifact comparison, approval preservation, trust-boundary drift blocking, and audit trail.	`workflow_endurance_and_repair` plus `live_workflow_endurance_canary` with cockpit-visible final audit trail.	Can prove endurance canary behavior, but must not claim a durable workflow engine yet.	#440, PR #461
6	Durable workflow engine v1	Move workflow state beyond audit-projected receipts into minimal durable state: crash-safe resume, heartbeat or reactive trigger receipts, retry, repair, persisted snapshots, durable audit receipts, and delegated artifact review lifecycle.	Durable-state tests plus operator recovery receipts across crash, resume, failed-step, and delegated-artifact paths.	Landed in the proof train after the workflow endurance canary; future follow-ons must stay below production-grade orchestration claims.	#470
7	One excellent reach channel canary	One selected external channel proves pairing, revocation, health, retry, thread continuity, memory/context continuity, approval handoff, degraded UI, and external-message-to-audited-action flow.	M4 reach proof plus Activity Ledger and cockpit receipts.	Should follow security, replay, memory-quality, and workflow-endurance proof unless the Project explicitly promotes it.	#438, superseded PR #462, accepted proof in PR #473
8	Guardian world-model learning quality v2	Deepen stale and conflicting evidence arbitration, salience/confidence calibration, false-positive and false-negative accounting, restraint, and follow-through.	`guardian_learning_arbitration_v2` plus `/api/operator/guardian-learning-arbitration`, covering act, defer, bundle, clarify, approval, and stay-silent outcomes with explicit negative-case receipts.	Landed in the proof train after replay and memory-quality proof; future external-channel follow-ons should only join after reach continuity is proven.	#471
9	Governed extension marketplace hardening	Mature pack review, verification, compatibility semantics, supply-chain policy, provider trust downgrade handling, rollback posture, and authoring ergonomics.	`governed_capability_pack_hardening` review, compatibility, downgrade, permission-creep, supply-chain suspicion, rollback, and operator-surface receipts, alongside `m9_governed_ecosystem`.	Depends on secure execution and M1/M9 manifest contracts; do not claim production marketplace security.	#472
10	Guardian-safe multimodal and voice proof	Voice, TTS/STT, browser vision, image/media analysis, and media delivery exist only as governed capability families with owner, trust, permission, data-access, audit, privacy, continuity, correction/deletion, and revocation receipts.	`guardian_safe_multimodal_voice` plus `/api/operator/guardian-safe-multimodal-voice`, showing channel safety plus actual guardian value.	Landed as a proof-gate slice; does not claim live broad voice/media runtime, voice parity, or multimodal parity.	#467

Feature Traceability

Research feature area	Canonical implementation phase	Guardian value gate	Blocked claim if failing
Capability kernel	Phases 0, 1, 9	Every capability must expose source, owner, trust level, permission, health, dependency, recovery, and operator receipt before memory or guardian policy can rely on it.	capability parity, governed ecosystem depth
Secure capability host	Phase 1	The cockpit must explain both the mechanical boundary and the guardian reason for restraint, approval, refusal, or clarification.	secure execution, IronClaw-class security, production security
Guardian memory	Phase 4	Memory must change action choice, timing, channel, restraint, clarification, recovery, or follow-through, not merely increase stored context.	memory superiority, behavior-changing recall
Intervention intelligence	Phase 8	Better intervention means fewer bad interventions, clearer deferrals, stronger clarification, safer approvals, and grounded stay-silent decisions.	intervention superiority, guardian brain advantage
Workflow endurance	Phases 5 and 6	Long work must stay legible across interruptions, branches, failures, approvals, artifacts, and delegated ownership.	workflow superiority, durable workflow readiness
Operator cockpit	Phase 3	The operator must move from "what happened?" to "what should I do next?" through receipts and controls, not source diving.	cockpit efficiency, operator superiority
Selective reach	Phase 7	Reach must preserve memory, thread identity, approvals, audit, and recovery across surfaces while rejecting channel sprawl.	OpenClaw-style reach parity, always-available operation
Browser/computer use	Phases 1, 2, 7	Browser work must carry session partitioning, credential boundaries, replay receipts, and workflow/artifact continuity.	browser/computer-use parity, safe browser automation
Ecosystem and marketplace	Phase 9	Extensions must remain subordinate to Seraph's trust, review, compatibility, rollback, and guardian-governance model.	marketplace maturity, governed ecosystem superiority
Multimodal and voice	Phase 10	Voice/media must improve timing, accessibility, situational awareness, or intervention quality, and must show transcript/audit/privacy receipts.	multimodal parity, voice parity, guardian-safe voice

Feature Batch Template

Every post-EF batch that claims progress against research document 20 should include:

user-facing capability: the screen, command, API, workflow, control, recovery path, channel, memory behavior, security behavior, marketplace flow, or browser action that improves
non-duplication statement: which closed proof/control batches it builds on and what it deliberately does not reimplement
implementation scope: concrete backend, frontend, runtime, memory, security, connector, marketplace, or browser modules owned by the batch
acceptance criteria: observable behavior a real operator can use, not just a new benchmark or claim receipt
local sanity: the focused checks needed to avoid shipping broken feature code
blocked claims: the words or claims that remain disallowed until the final claim-readiness phase
linked issue or PR: the GitHub object that owns acceptance and review

Proof-only fields such as new benchmark suites, broad receipt surfaces, source refreshes, false-completion scans, and claim-ledger lift wording belong in the separate claim-readiness phase after the feature train has shipped.

Strategic Order

The durable post-EF order is:

Durable orchestration features that make long-running work easier to resume, inspect, recover, and trust.
Secure capability-host features that make risky tool, connector, browser, package, and credential paths visibly safer and recoverable.
Reach and channel features that make selected channels genuinely usable for daily interruption, approval, recovery, and continuity.
Guardian learning and memory features that visibly improve decisions, restraint, recall, correction, and provider conflict handling.
Operator debugging and recovery-control features that make the cockpit a real control surface for serious work.
Capability marketplace lifecycle features that make install, update, disable, rollback, quarantine, and diagnostics understandable and reversible.
Browser/computer-use features that make runs more reliable, explainable, recoverable, and bounded when sites drift or credentials/sessions are involved.
One final claim-readiness phase for receipts, focused tests, docs, board reconciliation, source refresh, false-completion scans, and exact claim-ledger wording.

This order intentionally differs from raw competitor feature order. Seraph should expand capability breadth only when the guardian, trust, memory, workflow, and operator-control layers can carry it. During the feature phase, receipt work remains subordinate to shipping the capability.

Critic / Contrarian Disposition

Accepted:

Research document 20 should remain a competitor-pressure overlay; implementation order belongs here and live execution belongs in the Project.
The roadmap must not duplicate closed M0-M9 anchors or the active #438/#439/#440/#441/#467 proof issues.
Closed #422 must not be used as the parent for new work.
Selective reach must not outrun secure execution, replay proof, cockpit legibility, memory quality, and workflow endurance unless the Project deliberately promotes it.
Board receipt language must distinguish tool-confirmed PR merge state from issue/project fields that require separate confirmation.
Feature rows need guardian value gates, not only parity surfaces.

Rejected:

The roadmap should not remove implementation sequencing entirely. The user explicitly asked for a roadmap to implement the full research document, so this file records durable sequencing while keeping active task state in GitHub.

Accepted after follow-up:

The remaining roadmap-level follow-ons were created as Project items and then promoted into the aggregate proof train once their prerequisite evidence was available. #470, #471, and #472 were integrated through merged PR #473, while their child issue PR fields remain Not Ready because the parent hub owned the aggregate PR relationship.
A duplicate secure execution host v1 ticket was not created because closed #455 already owns that batch; future secure-host work needs a narrowed follow-up with named uncovered negative cases.

Post-merge disposition:

PR #473 completed the original proof train, while the production train now carries bounded BV-EF receipts and feature-control batches under #475. That work improved the evidence layer, but it did not finish product parity. The accepted June 18 correction is that post-EF work must pursue user-facing feature parity first and defer new proof wrappers or claim-lift gates until one final claim-readiness phase. Production readiness, product-wide full parity, reference-system exceedance, secure/private-by-default, safe autonomous browser/computer-use, full browser parity, solved durable workflows, solved operator-control, guardian-superiority, memory-superiority, marketplace superiority, and ecosystem-superiority wording still requires exact claim-ledger permission after the feature train and final claim-readiness pass.

Status For develop​

Paired Research​

Purpose​

Execution Boundary​

Board Receipts​

Production-Grade Parity Execution Train​

Roadmap Phases​

Feature Traceability​

Feature Batch Template​

Strategic Order​

Critic / Contrarian Disposition​