09. Benchmark Status

Status On develop

When this file is updated on an open feature branch, checked items describe the intended post-merge develop state. The open PR remains the integration truth until it merges.

• The capability import program and benchmark refresh are now landed on develop.
• Seraph now also has an operator-visible benchmark-proof surface with explicit deterministic suite coverage across memory, workflows, replay, security, cockpit, reach, guardian judgment, governed improvement, M9 ecosystem governance, durable workflow state, durable-orchestration v2, live external-orchestration/crash-study attestation, one-channel reach, production reach-channel hardening, browser/computer-use reliability v2, guardian-safe voice/media runtime, live broad reach channel attestation, production voice/media provider runtime, cross-surface continuity recovery, broad channel SLA operations, production voice/media quality gates, mobile execution continuity, broad reach field operations, voice/media quality operations, always-available reach SLOs, always-available reach operations v1, voice/media parity runtime v1, mobile cross-surface continuity v1, reach degraded recovery field campaign, always-available reach live ops v1, voice/media production parity-candidate receipts, channel incident response, cross-surface reach continuity v2, reach/media false-claim scanning, guardian learning arbitration, live guardian-learning quality, intervention outcome cohorts, memory-provider ecosystem maturity, canonical memory reconciliation v2, provider usefulness regressions, live human outcome quality studies, guardian-learning causal attribution, memory-provider live regression monitors, independent outcome cohort review, task-scoped causal learning, memory-provider parity matrix, longitudinal guardian outcome studies, named baseline memory comparisons, learning safety monitors v2, live long-horizon guardian field studies, memory behavior-change ablations, live memory-provider parity operations, independent guardian outcome reviews, longitudinal learning safety monitors v3, post-DP guardian learning/memory gap-closure receipts, long-horizon learning quality v2 receipts, memory behavior ablation v2 receipts, memory-provider operation v2 receipts, learning-safety regression v2 receipts, guardian-memory false-claim scan v2 receipts, governed capability-pack hardening, marketplace lifecycle maturity, live marketplace attestation and operations, production marketplace-security receipts, marketplace registry-corpus operations, continuous vulnerability monitoring, publisher trust operations, production-secure marketplace v1 receipts, third-party package-security certification receipts, marketplace live-corpus operations v2, hostile package lifecycle gauntlet receipts, marketplace production-security certification-track receipts, live-ops v2 receipts, ecosystem supply-chain operations, hostile package lifecycle v2 gauntlets, publisher trust vulnerability ops, marketplace false-claim scans, browser-provider attestation, multi-operator usability, browser recovery drills, browser task-breadth and auth-partition operations, site-drift recovery SLOs, production operator control parity, production parity train verification, operator-control certification v1, mission-control population study v2, long-work recovery SLO v2, operator error detectability v1, operator-control certification v2, live population telemetry, tamper-evident audit candidate receipts, authority-transfer recovery receipts, operator-control false-claim scans, final source-backed parity audit, final claim-ledger reconciliation, operator final parity readiness reporting, post-CQ claim-ledger reconciliation, reference-system source refresh v2, false-completion scan v2, final production-readiness soak-readiness reconciliation receipts, final full-parity claim-lift receipts, reference-system manual source refresh v3, false-completion scan v3, board/PR/issue reconciliation v3, production orchestration hard-guarantee receipts, distributed workflow recovery operations, external side-effect correctness v4, scheduler failover soak, and orchestration false-claim scans.
• Batch CU adds benchmark-proof coverage for broad_reach_field_operations, voice_media_quality_operations, and always_available_reach_slo, with /api/operator/broad-reach-field-ops exposing provider/channel field-operation receipts, redacted metadata-only receipt boundaries, continuity IDs, voice/media quality gates, bounded SLO/offline recovery, coverage gaps, and blocked claims.
• Batch DC adds benchmark-proof coverage for always_available_reach_operations_v1, voice_media_parity_runtime_v1, mobile_cross_surface_continuity_v1, and reach_degraded_recovery_field_campaign, with /api/operator/always-available-reach-media exposing selected-channel campaign receipts, voice/media runtime quality and latency receipts, cross-surface continuity, 14-day equivalent degraded recovery metrics, false/missed delivery metrics, operator repair actions, redacted receipts, and blocked claims.
• Batch DK adds benchmark-proof coverage for always_available_reach_live_ops_v1, voice_media_production_parity_candidate_v1, channel_incident_response_v1, cross_surface_reach_continuity_v2, and reach_media_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/reach-voice-production-ops exposing selected live/degraded channel windows, provider identity, consent/pairing/revocation receipts, rate-limit and abuse handling, provider incident response, offline recovery, false/missed delivery metrics, voice/media quality and latency candidates, cross-surface thread/memory/approval/notification/operator-handoff continuity, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DS adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_reach_channel_gap_closure_v1, selected_reach_surface_readiness_v2, channel_degraded_recovery_v2, guardian_reach_continuity_v2, voice_media_privacy_fallback_v2, and reach_channel_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-reach-channel-gap-closure exposing selected native_notification and websocket reach readiness, consent/pairing/revocation, degraded recovery, guardian-aware timing/restraint continuity, voice/media privacy fallback, staged channel gaps, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DL adds benchmark-proof coverage for live_long_horizon_guardian_learning_field_study_v1, memory_behavior_change_ablation_v1, live_memory_provider_parity_operations_v1, independent_guardian_outcome_candidate_review_v1, longitudinal_learning_safety_monitor_v3, and guardian_memory_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/live-guardian-memory-field-program exposing pre-registered field windows, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, fixture-vs-live markers, memory-enabled behavior changes against memory-disabled or memory-limited counterfactuals, canonical/advisory/degraded/stale/conflicting/privacy-limited provider operations, delete/export propagation, quarantine, reinstatement, independent review, learning safety negative cases, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DT adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_guardian_learning_memory_gap_closure_v1, long_horizon_learning_quality_v2, memory_behavior_ablation_v2, memory_provider_operation_v2, learning_safety_regression_v2, and guardian_memory_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-guardian-learning-memory-gap-closure exposing consented long-horizon cohorts, withdrawal/anonymization/adverse review, memory-enabled versus memory-limited decision ablations, reversible learning deltas, stale-evidence decay, rollback authority, provider quarantine/reinstatement, delete/export propagation, learning-safety negative cases, safe redacted receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, real claim-scan command evidence, and blocked claims.
• Batch DM adds benchmark-proof coverage for operator_control_certification_v2, operator_control_live_population_v1, tamper_evident_audit_candidate_v1, authority_transfer_recovery_v1, and operator_control_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/operator-control-production-certification exposing required dense long-work controls, stale-approval blocking, safe denial, recovery correctness, operator takeover, recorded-live plus fixture population telemetry, keyboard/accessibility floors, digest-linked tamper-evident audit candidate receipts, unauthorized mutation denial, authority-transfer scope renewal, replay/runbook boundaries, redacted safe receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DU adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_operator_debugging_recovery_control_v1, dense_long_work_debugging_v2, operator_recovery_slo_v3, operator_effort_reduction_v2, authority_transfer_integrity_v2, operator_audit_accessibility_v2, and operator_control_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-operator-debugging-recovery-control exposing root-cause/artifact/recovery visibility, required recovery controls, stale-approval and broadened-scope fail-closed cases, safe denial, operator effort receipts, authority-transfer integrity, digest-linked audit and accessibility receipts, real claim-scan command evidence, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DN adds benchmark-proof coverage for marketplace_security_certification_track_v1, production_secure_marketplace_live_ops_v2, ecosystem_supply_chain_operations_v1, hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v2, publisher_trust_vulnerability_ops_v1, and marketplace_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/marketplace-production-security exposing certification-track review scope, finding/retest/waiver expiry, provenance/signature/publisher-key/SBOM/dependency evidence, computed scanner freshness, install/update/downgrade/rollback/quarantine/re-entry operations, hostile lifecycle v2 denials, publisher trust and vulnerability operations, redacted safe receipt handles, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DV adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_capability_marketplace_lifecycle_gap_closure_v1, marketplace_lifecycle_operations_v3, package_review_waiver_policy_v2, marketplace_vulnerability_monitoring_v2, hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v3, marketplace_rollback_quarantine_diagnostics_v2, marketplace_secure_host_audit_integration_v1, and marketplace_lifecycle_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-marketplace-lifecycle-gap-closure exposing lifecycle transition receipts, provenance/signature/publisher/SBOM/dependency/vulnerability/compatibility/permission/trust-tier fields, high/critical waiver-denial policy, scanner freshness, hostile lifecycle denials, rollback/quarantine diagnostics, secure-host permission/audit integration, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DW adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_browser_computer_use_reliability_v1, browser_live_provider_reliability_v2, browser_session_boundary_enforcement_v3, browser_credentialed_recovery_v2, browser_site_drift_recovery_v3, browser_hostile_page_safety_v2, browser_provider_degradation_v2, and browser_computer_use_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-browser-computer-use-reliability exposing a CH/CP/CY/DG/DO/DP non-duplication delta matrix, selected provider degradation, no-silent-fallback behavior, session/profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/clipboard/network/private-data boundary receipts under recovery pressure, credentialed test-account recovery, site-drift authority preservation, hostile-page fail-closed receipts, artifact provenance, negative proof validators, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DX adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dq_dw_board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v1, post_dq_dw_claim_ledger_reconciliation_v1, reference_system_source_refresh_v5, false_completion_scan_v5, and post_dq_dw_critic_contrarian_no_block_v1, with /api/operator/post-dq-dw-claim-readiness exposing DQ-DX Done/Merged/Passed board receipts, PR #589 merge state, SCL-059 through SCL-066 reconciliation, 2026-06-12 Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw stored source-refresh receipts, X article access caveat, false-completion scans, Critic/Contrarian receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DY adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dx_live_durable_orchestration_v1, recorded_live_orchestration_window_v1, crash_restart_failover_drill_v3, multi_agent_handoff_durability_v2, side_effect_reconciliation_v6, operator_recovery_control_v4, and orchestration_false_claim_scan_v3, with /api/operator/post-dx-live-durable-orchestration exposing recorded-live and accelerated orchestration windows, scheduler/provider jitter, crash/restart/failover drills, replay authority, duplicate suppression, side-effect reconciliation, multi-agent handoff durability, operator recovery controls, residual-risk markers, false-claim scans, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DZ adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dx_formal_secure_runtime_isolation_v1, runtime_isolation_attestation_evidence_v2, credential_broker_egress_enforcement_v3, hostile_chain_containment_v4, external_security_review_certification_track_v2, secure_runtime_recovery_authority_v3, and secure_runtime_false_claim_scan_v3, with /api/operator/post-dx-formal-secure-runtime-isolation exposing runtime-attestation evidence, credential-broker egress enforcement, hostile-chain containment, external review/certification-track records, operator recovery authority, unsupported hardware-backed and TEE/CVM/Wasm/container markers, command-backed false-claim scans, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch EA adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dx_reach_voice_media_parity_proof_v1, multi_channel_reach_reliability_v3, voice_media_quality_latency_v3, reach_abuse_recovery_v3, cross_surface_reach_continuity_v3, and reach_voice_media_false_claim_scan_v3, with /api/operator/post-dx-reach-voice-media-parity-proof exposing selected and candidate multi-channel reliability, provider identity, consent, pairing, revocation, false/missed delivery metrics, rate limits, abuse handling, degraded/offline recovery, voice/media quality and latency gates, correction/deletion/privacy controls, provider-regression fallback, cross-surface continuity, coverage gaps, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch EB adds operator-visible live-control coverage for guardian learning and memory through /api/memory/live-controls, /api/memory/guardian-memory-live-control, /api/operator/memory-live-controls, and /api/operator/guardian-memory-live-control, exposing learning-impact review, stale-evidence decay, provider quarantine/reinstatement, usefulness triage, rollback authority, delete/export propagation visibility, privacy-boundary validation, trusted provenance, safe recovery, and blocked claims.
• Batch EC adds operator-visible live workflow-control coverage through /api/workflows/runs/{run_identity}/control, exposing pause, resume, cancel, retry, redirect, recover, replay-aware control receipts, lease and resume-plan boundaries, refusal/audit behavior, and blocked exactly-once/crash-proof/solved-workflow claims.
• Batch ED adds operator-visible marketplace lifecycle-control coverage through extension review, quarantine, re-entry, rollback, install, and update surfaces, exposing lifecycle decisions, permission/provenance boundaries, rollback authority, recovery state, and blocked production-secure marketplace/full-marketplace-parity claims.
• Batch EE adds operator-visible browser/computer-use live-control coverage through /api/browser/sessions, /api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/snapshot, /api/browser/sessions/{session_id}/control, and /api/operator/browser-computer-use-control, exposing owner-scoped sessions, provider degradation, no-silent-fallback replay acknowledgement, partition reset, boundary decisions, redacted provenance, recovery actions, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked safe-browser/full-browser-parity claims.
• Batch EF adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_dx_final_board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v1, post_dx_final_claim_ledger_reconciliation_v1, reference_system_source_refresh_v6, false_completion_scan_v6, and post_dx_final_critic_contrarian_no_block_v1, with /api/operator/post-dx-final-parity-claim-lift exposing DY-EE issue/PR/Project reconciliation, SCL-067 through SCL-072 reconciliation, June 18, 2026 Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw pressure-only source receipts, X article access caveat, false-completion scans, Critic/Contrarian receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, exact SCL-072 bounded wording, and blocked broad parity/exceedance claims.
• Batch DO adds benchmark-proof coverage for browser_computer_use_production_safety_v1, safe_browser_automation_live_ops_v1, credentialed_site_recovery_v1, browser_provider_parity_candidate_v1, browser_session_partition_attestation_v2, and browser_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/browser-computer-use-production exposing provider identity and support states, session/profile/cookie/credential/download/upload/filesystem/clipboard/network/private-data boundaries, hostile-page fail-closed cases, dangerous-action policy, recorded-live safe-target operations, credentialed test-account recovery, provider degradation, existing-session blocks, redacted safe receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DP added benchmark-proof coverage for full_parity_claim_lift_audit_v1, production_readiness_reconciliation_v2, reference_system_source_refresh_v4, post_di_do_board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v1, false_completion_scan_v4, and final_critic_contrarian_no_block_v1, with /api/operator/full-parity-release-gate exposing post-DI-DO claim-lift decisions, seven-area production-readiness reconciliation receipts, current 2026-06-11 Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw pressure-only source receipts, DI-DO issue/PR/Project reconciliation, stale issue-body caveats, false-completion scans, Critic/Contrarian no-block receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch DR added benchmark-proof coverage for post_dp_secure_capability_host_gap_closure_v1, runtime_profile_selection_v2, deny_default_credential_egress_v2, hostile_capability_chain_quarantine_v2, secure_host_recovery_authority_v2, and secure_host_false_claim_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-dp-secure-capability-host exposing explicit runtime profile selection, deny-by-default egress, scoped credential refs, hostile cross-surface quarantine, operator-owned recovery authority, safe redacted receipts, aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, and blocked claims.
• Batch CV adds benchmark-proof coverage for longitudinal_guardian_outcome_study, named_baseline_memory_comparison, and learning_safety_monitor_v2, with /api/operator/longitudinal-guardian-outcomes exposing 60-plus day outcome windows, named baseline pressure evidence, independent evaluator protocol, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, adverse-event review, rollback, provider quarantine/reinstatement, delete/export propagation, safe redacted receipts, and blocked claims.
• Batch CW adds benchmark-proof coverage for operator_control_population_study, named_baseline_cockpit_comparison, and long_work_debugging_slo, with /api/operator/operator-control-population-study exposing population-study metrics, pressure-only named cockpit baselines, timeline/log-diff/replay/runbook/handoff mission-control receipts, redacted safe receipt handles, receiver scope-renewal handoff, read-only replay/runbook boundaries, and blocked claims.
• Batch DE adds benchmark-proof coverage for operator_control_certification_v1, mission_control_population_study_v2, long_work_recovery_slo_v2, and operator_error_detectability_v1, with /api/operator/operator-control-certification exposing required-control coverage, task-relative telemetry, accessibility and keyboard-only paths, stale approval blocking, safe denial, confidence calibration, recovery correctness, pressure-only named baselines, redacted tamper-evident receipts, and blocked claims.
• Batch CX adds benchmark-proof coverage for marketplace_security_corpus_v1, continuous_vulnerability_monitoring, and publisher_trust_operations, with /api/operator/marketplace-security-corpus exposing registry corpus package families, provenance/signature/publisher-key/SBOM/dependency receipts, scanner freshness, waiver/remediation policy, publisher trust operations, lifecycle diagnostics, package-network/secret/workspace denial receipts, redacted safe receipt handles, and blocked claims.
• Batch DF adds benchmark-proof coverage for production_secure_marketplace_v1, third_party_package_security_certification_v1, marketplace_live_corpus_operations_v2, and hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v1, with /api/operator/production-secure-marketplace exposing bounded production-gate receipts, proof-bound reviewer/certification-scope records, larger live-corpus quality, fail-closed lifecycle operations, expanded hostile package drills, redacted safe receipt digests, and blocked claims.
• Batch CY adds benchmark-proof coverage for browser_task_breadth_matrix, browser_auth_partition_operations, and site_drift_recovery_slo, with /api/operator/browser-computer-use-parity-depth exposing safe-target browser task breadth, provider identity, reliability windows, auth/session partition operations, dangerous-action blocks, site-drift recovery SLOs, prior CP safety-boundary linkage, and blocked claims.
• Batch DG adds benchmark-proof coverage for safe_autonomous_browser_runtime_v1, full_browser_parity_matrix_v1, real_site_drift_recovery_v2, and browser_session_partition_certification_v1, with /api/operator/full-browser-parity exposing bounded safe-target runtime evidence, provider execution caveats, blocked existing-session attachment, boundary matrices, hostile-browser negative cases, partition certification-scope records, redacted safe receipts, and blocked claims.
• Batch DH adds benchmark-proof coverage for production_readiness_soak_v1, final_full_parity_claim_lift_v1, reference_system_source_refresh_v3, false_completion_scan_v3, and board_pr_issue_reconciliation_v3, with /api/operator/final-production-parity exposing DA-DG reconciliation, June 11, 2026 manual reference-system source-review receipts, seven-area soak-readiness reconciliation receipts, exact claim-lift decisions, stale PR closure evidence, false-completion scans, and Critic/Contrarian dispositions.
• Batch DI adds benchmark-proof coverage for production_orchestration_hard_guarantees_v1, distributed_workflow_recovery_operations_v1, external_side_effect_correctness_v4, scheduler_failover_soak_v1, and orchestration_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/production-orchestration-hard-guarantees exposing durable queue/scheduler lease receipts, worker failover, replay authority, distributed recovery operations, side-effect correctness v4, accelerated fixture soak receipts with missing-live-window markers, operator recovery controls, false-claim scans, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
• Batch DJ adds benchmark-proof coverage for production_grade_secure_capability_host_evidence_v1, secure_host_cross_surface_attack_chain_v1, credential_broker_egress_soak_v1, runtime_isolation_attestation_matrix_v1, secure_host_operator_recovery_authority_v1, and secure_host_false_claim_scan_v1, with /api/operator/production-grade-secure-capability-host exposing cross-surface hostile-chain receipts, credential-egress soak fixtures, runtime-attestation matrices, operator recovery authority, redacted digest receipts, false-claim scans, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility.
• Batch CZ adds benchmark-proof coverage for post_cq_claim_ledger_reconciliation, reference_system_source_refresh_v2, and false_completion_scan_v2, with /api/operator/post-cq-claim-readiness exposing static 2026-06-11 Hermes/OpenClaw/IronClaw source receipts backed by external Critic/Contrarian reachability review, CR-CY issue/PR/operator snapshot reconciliation with live GitHub Project verification required in the PR workflow, SCL-034 through SCL-041 claim-ledger receipts, clean local false-completion scans plus an external GitHub PR/issue scan gate, accepted Critic/Contrarian fixes, and blocked claims.
• Seraph still cannot credibly claim broad benchmark superiority from implementation alone.

M0 claim gate:

• 19. Strategy Claim Ledger owns allowed wording for broad superiority, world-class, best, strongest, secure, private, production-ready, complete, and ahead-of-competitor claims.

Paired Research

• benchmark source of truth: 10. Competitive Benchmark
• evidence rules: 09. Reference Systems And Evidence
• M0 competitor truth: 18. Agent Competition Truth Table
• M0 claim and wording gate: 19. Strategy Claim Ledger

Purpose

This file is the implementation-side mirror of the competitive benchmark.

Research owns the comparison against OpenClaw, Hermes, and IronClaw. This file owns three implementation questions:

1. what is already shipped on develop for each benchmark axis?
2. what is still missing before Seraph can credibly claim Ahead on that axis?
3. which implementation workstreams own that gap?

Axis Status On develop

Axis	Checklist	Shipped On develop	Biggest Missing Piece	Owning Workstreams
Operator visibility and legibility	[ ]	audit trails, visible tool streaming, session traces, workflow-run views, step records, replay/resume drafts, grouped Activity Ledger rows with runtime-path spend attribution, imported capability reach summaries, extension governance queues, browser mode and connector inventory, operations inspector, persisted layouts, active triage, evidence shortcuts, workflow step-focus rows with direct context/output handoff, branch-origin and failure-lineage debugger rows, family-history comparison plus output-comparison drafts, family-row checkpoint drill-in, family-row retry/repair controls, bundled workflow-family next-step planning drafts, denser ancestor/peer/failure-lineage follow-through rows, triage workflow quick actions, direct triage failure-context and recovery control, a dedicated workflow-supervision lane with history/branch/recovery summaries, a workspace-level multi-session workflow-orchestration lane, explicit long-run workflow state capsules with visible-versus-compacted step counts plus preserved recovery paths, anticipatory repair drafts, backup-branch candidates, condensation-fidelity state, a workspace-level background-session substrate that joins session-owned processes with branch handoff and continuity snippets, searchable repository or pull-request engineering-memory bundles that join workflow continuity, approval targets, audit receipts, artifact paths, and matched session snippets by shared reference, an explicit continuity graph linking sessions/workflows/approvals/artifacts/notifications/deferred guardian items, a background-continuity supervision lane that composes those three operator continuity surfaces into one direct handoff/control view, an operator-visible guardian-state surface for confidence and explanation, keyboard-first inspect/approve/continue/latest-branch/best-continuation/comparison/failure/recovery/redirect control, thread-aware continue/open-thread controls, the named m7_operator_cockpit_legibility deterministic suite proving operator-readable review/routing receipts plus control-mode-labeled approval/workflow/continuity fast controls in the control-plane payload, the named cockpit_operator_efficiency_benchmark deterministic suite proving thresholded scripted-task fixtures, scorecard budgets, receipt coverage, and confidence-affordance claim boundaries, and Batch CH live_multi_operator_usability_study receipts for recorded-live inspect/recover/approval/handoff/audit/keyboard/accessibility/error-rate metrics	deeper step-level execution control, broader cross-surface command control, real click/keystroke telemetry, broad independent usability evidence, and solved-control proof beyond the shipped branch-debug, workflow-supervision, multi-session orchestration plus state-capsule compaction, anticipatory repair or backup-branch guidance, background-session substrate, engineering-memory bundle layer, continuity-graph layer, background-continuity supervision lane, guardian-state explanation lane, comparison, bundled family-planning, triage quick-action layer, deterministic M7 receipt/control proof, deterministic cockpit-efficiency proxy proof, and Batch CH recorded-live multi-operator usability receipts	06, 03, 07
Longitudinal memory and human modeling	[ ]	guardian record, vector memory, consolidation, priorities, observer context, explicit guardian state, calibrated salience/confidence scoring, context packs, session search, and a structured world-model layer for focus, focus provenance, commitments, projects, recurring patterns, constraints, routines, memory signals, continuity threads, execution pressure, receptivity, judgment risks, explicit project-ranking diagnostics, stale-signal arbitration notes, cross-thread follow-through carryover, cross-source project arbitration on the live project, explicit live-versus-procedural learning-conflict diagnostics, conservative ambiguity guardrails when project-anchor competition lines up with negative outcome trends, an explicit user-model substrate with inferred interruption or communication or thread or cadence preferences plus grounded-versus-partial confidence and evidence diagnostics, explicit user-model evidence facets plus action-posture/restraint-reason state, explicit intent-uncertainty diagnostics with clarify-versus-caution resolution guidance, explicit judgment-proof lines for split evidence and ambiguous referents, an operator-visible guardian-state explanation surface, a dedicated guardian_memory_quality benchmark suite for reasoning-heavy retrieval, contradiction-aware ranking, selective forgetting, and operator-visible failure reporting, a dedicated m6_memory_superiority benchmark suite for long-horizon recall, contradiction handling, stale-memory override, source trust/privacy boundaries, provider-quality diagnostics, and receipted behavior change, a dedicated memory_provider_quality_gate suite for pre-context provider declarations, quality-gated recall improvement, noisy/stale/conflict/privacy suppression, and operator-visible claim boundaries, a dedicated guardian_user_model_restraint benchmark suite for continuity-aware user modeling and restraint-before-action proof, Batch BZ memory_provider_ecosystem_maturity_v1, canonical_memory_reconciliation_v2, and provider_usefulness_regression suites for provider usefulness/degradation/quarantine, canonical precedence, advisory writeback, deletion/export receipts, and provider behavior-change regressions, Batch CF memory_provider_live_regression_monitor receipts for live-window usefulness deltas, stale-evidence decay, privacy regression monitoring, quarantine, and reviewable reversal, Batch CM independent_outcome_cohort_review, task_scoped_causal_learning, and memory_provider_parity_matrix receipts for independent evaluator metadata, sample and power rationale, consent/anonymization, adverse-event review, bounded outcome claims, task-scoped counterfactual causal receipts, rollback authority, canonical/advisory provider comparison, privacy-regression quarantine, and delete/export receipts, Batch CV longitudinal_guardian_outcome_study, named_baseline_memory_comparison, and learning_safety_monitor_v2 receipts for 60-plus day outcome windows, named baseline pressure evidence, rollback, quarantine/reinstatement, delete/export propagation, and safe redacted receipt boundaries, Batch DD generalized_guardian_outcome_study_v1, full_memory_provider_parity_matrix_v1, causal_learning_outcome_thresholds_v1, and memory_baseline_comparison_v1 receipts for predeclared multi-decision outcome protocols, expanded provider dimension matrices, causal thresholds, current-source-limited pressure baselines, redacted receipts, and blocked claims, plus a provider-neutral adapter model with per-capability sync contracts, a machine-readable canonical-memory contract, explicit provider provenance taxonomy, additive memory-provider usefulness diagnostics, provenance lines, query-matched canonical project hints for provider-backed user-model augmentation, explicit canonical-memory reconciliation diagnostics, guarded post-canonical writeback that suppresses project-anchorless project-scoped mirrors, and pre-context provider evidence gates for evidence ID, confidence, privacy, freshness, conflict, and suppression declarations	live-provider workload breadth, external-provider attestation, generalized outcome-superiority and memory-superiority evidence beyond Batch DD, and broader memory-provider ecosystems without giving up the guardian-first canonical memory model	05
Intervention quality and timing	[ ]	strategist, proactive scheduler surfaces, explicit intervention policy, observer salience/confidence/interruption-cost scoring, calibrated high-salience timing overrides, persisted intervention outcomes, explicit user feedback capture, native-notification fallback, channel routing, messaging reach, a first multi-signal delivery/channel/escalation/timing/blocked-state learning layer with scoped live global/thread/project resolution, contradiction-aware guardian confidence downgrades when durable project recall conflicts with live observer context, a first long-horizon pass that treats stale supporting recall plus stale execution pressure as contradictions against the live project anchor, inspectable live-learning diagnostics for scope and long-horizon spread, explicit diagnostics for when live outcomes overrule procedural guidance versus when procedural memory still wins, guardian-state intent-uncertainty guidance that can recommend clarify-versus-caution instead of forcing a confident intervention, explicit split-evidence judgment proof for why the guardian is clarifying or proceeding conservatively, explicit action-posture plus restraint-reason surfaces that carry clarify-first or defer-first judgment into the operator path, a named guardian_user_model_restraint benchmark suite for ambiguity-aware clarification and restraint, a named m8_guardian_intervention_quality benchmark suite plus /api/operator/m8-guardian-brain receipts covering act/defer/bundle/clarify/request-approval/stay-silent choices, selected and rejected capability lanes, timing/usefulness/false-positive/false-negative/trust/recovery labels, and approval-preserving high-risk capability use, the first long-horizon abstention policy that can bundle or defer low-urgency guidance plus defer unstable scheduled reviews when outcome history degrades, Batch BZ live_guardian_learning_quality and guardian_intervention_outcome_cohorts suites plus /api/operator/live-guardian-learning-quality receipts for accepted/ignored/corrected/deferred/harmful/helpful/channel-shifted/follow-through cohorts, policy deltas, stale-evidence decay, and false-positive/false-negative learning receipts, Batch CF live_human_outcome_quality_study and guardian_learning_causal_attribution suites plus /api/operator/live-human-outcome-learning-proof receipts for consent-aware anonymized recorded-live cohorts, correction/harm/follow-through evidence, residual bias and coverage limitations, counterfactual causal attribution, and reversible learning changes, Batch CM independent_outcome_cohort_review and task_scoped_causal_learning receipts plus /api/operator/independent-learning-memory-parity for independent evaluator metadata, sample and power rationale, consent/anonymization, adverse-event review, bounded outcome claims, counterfactual task-scoped causal attribution, confounder boundaries, and rollback authority, Batch CV longitudinal_guardian_outcome_study and learning_safety_monitor_v2 receipts plus /api/operator/longitudinal-guardian-outcomes for 60-plus day windows, independent evaluator protocol, consent/withdrawal/anonymization, adverse-event review, reversible learning-policy deltas, rollback, and safety-monitor blocks, Batch DD generalized_guardian_outcome_study_v1 and causal_learning_outcome_thresholds_v1 receipts plus /api/operator/generalized-guardian-outcomes for predeclared multi-decision outcome protocols, fairness and adverse-event review, counterfactual causal thresholds, promotion gates, rollback authority, redacted receipts, and blocked claims, a named guardian_safe_multimodal_voice proof gate proving voice/media capability families need explicit guardian-value reasons before they can become reach, and Batch CE production_voice_media_provider_runtime plus cross_surface_continuity_recovery receipts for consent, capture boundaries, correction/deletion, provider-failure fallback, and thread/memory/approval continuity across voice/media handoff	generalized outcome-superiority evidence beyond Batch DD, production STT/TTS quality studies, broader reach-surface intervention replay, and stronger adaptive learning beyond BZ plus M8 plus voice/media governance and CE provider receipts	05, 04
Safe real-world execution	[ ]	approvals, policy modes, sandboxed shell and execute-code paths, audit logging, secret handling, explicit secret-ref containment, field-scoped secret-ref injection surfaces, per-tool secret-ref metadata, permission summaries and approval profiles for packaged capabilities, suspicious-context scanning, site-policy controls, browser mode boundaries, underdeclared workflow/runtime rejection, allowlisted authenticated connector mutation payloads, session-bound managed-process recovery handles, explicit managed-process session/background trust metadata, always-confirm background process start for persistent runtime work, disposable worker runtime roots outside the workspace for direct command and background-process execution, allowlisted process environments, explicit credential-egress allowlists for secret-bearing MCP execution, destination-host checks for secret-ref egress, generic read/patch blocking for secret-like workspace paths, workspace escape blocking, browser cookie/session partition strategy receipts, hostile-provider replay blocking receipts, delegated/workflow/operator trust receipts that preserve branch-handoff and connector-egress partitions, a capability/trust regression matrix, patch preview/apply receipts with stable artifact lineage, a named trust_boundary_and_safety_receipts suite, a named secure_capability_host suite, a named production_secure_host_hardening suite, a named secure_capability_host_live_isolation_v2 suite, Batch CD production_isolation_hardening_v2, privileged_path_red_team_gauntlet_v2, and security_incident_recovery_drill suites plus /api/operator/production-isolation-hardening receipts for worker roots, browser profiles, connector credentials, extension quarantine, workflow trust guards, red-team blocks, incident recovery, credential rotation, and operator notification, Batch CK independent_secure_host_review, live_hostile_isolation_drills, and secure_host_recovery_authority suites plus /api/operator/independent-secure-host-review receipts for reviewer scope, finding remediation, hostile drills, isolation evidence matrices, recovery authority, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, Batch DJ production_grade_secure_capability_host_evidence_v1, secure_host_cross_surface_attack_chain_v1, credential_broker_egress_soak_v1, runtime_isolation_attestation_matrix_v1, secure_host_operator_recovery_authority_v1, and secure_host_false_claim_scan_v1 suites plus /api/operator/production-grade-secure-capability-host receipts for cross-surface hostile chains, credential egress, runtime-attestation matrices, operator recovery authority, false-claim scans, blocked claims, and aggregate benchmark-proof visibility, /api/operator/secure-capability-host-hardening receipts, and a named m2_execution_supremacy suite with operator-visible M2 readiness and #435 gauntlet posture	hardware-backed or container-grade privileged-path isolation implementation, external security certification, complete browser credential/cookie isolation beyond current partition and recovery-partition receipts, broader live computer-use depth, and broader cross-surface enforcement for future delegated/background/provider execution layers	01, 02
Runtime reliability and eval rigor	[ ]	fallback chains, weighted routing policy, strict provider safeguard routing, richer route planning with explicit budget steering, capability-gap and live-feedback penalties, retained-primary versus planning-winner comparison summaries, per-target live feedback plus production-readiness route diagnostics, structured runtime audit, runtime-path spend attribution, deterministic eval harness coverage across guardian flows, imported capability surfaces, workflow recovery, browser modes, activity-ledger attribution, and cockpit/control legibility, plus named production_parity_readiness, guardian_memory_quality, m6_memory_superiority, memory_provider_quality_gate, guardian_user_model_restraint, guardian_learning_arbitration_v2, live_guardian_learning_quality, guardian_intervention_outcome_cohorts, memory_provider_ecosystem_maturity_v1, canonical_memory_reconciliation_v2, provider_usefulness_regression, workflow_endurance_and_repair, live_workflow_endurance_canary, durable_workflow_engine_v1, production_durable_orchestration, durable_workflow_engine_v2, production_reach_channel_hardening, browser_computer_use_reliability_v2, guardian_safe_voice_media_runtime, live_broad_reach_channel_attestation, production_voice_media_provider_runtime, cross_surface_continuity_recovery, live_long_horizon_eval_replay_v1, m5_jobs_routines_workflows_delegation, trust_boundary_and_safety_receipts, secure_capability_host, production_secure_host_hardening, secure_capability_host_live_isolation_v2, m7_operator_cockpit_legibility, cockpit_operator_efficiency_benchmark, m9_governed_ecosystem, governed_capability_pack_hardening, marketplace_grade_capability_lifecycle, governed_capability_lifecycle_v2, capability_rollback_failure_diagnostics, third_party_marketplace_attestation, marketplace_operations_incident_drill, publisher_review_and_package_trust, marketplace_security_certification_track_v1, production_secure_marketplace_live_ops_v2, ecosystem_supply_chain_operations_v1, hostile_package_lifecycle_gauntlet_v2, publisher_trust_vulnerability_ops_v1, marketplace_false_claim_scan_v1, managed_browser_provider_attestation, live_multi_operator_usability_study, browser_computer_use_recovery_drill, and channels_presence_device_pairing suites with operator-visible failure reporting, including production parity readiness gates for batch proof paths, blocked claims, Project-field contracts, duplicate-scope guardrails, negative-case requirements, receipt-schema fields, current-source requirements, and validation receipts; secure-host host-isolation, workspace-escape, browser partition-strategy, hostile-provider replay, capability/trust-matrix, receipt-completeness, secure-host hardening receipts for secret replay/redaction, browser recovery partitioning, private-network egress, extension revocation, workflow/provider replay trust drift, provider quality-gate suppression, learning-arbitration negative-case receipts, Batch BZ outcome/provider/canonical/regression receipts, Batch CA marketplace lifecycle receipts for permission/risk deltas, cross-family coverage, rollback, failed-update recovery, quarantine re-entry, diagnostics, and package-count claim blocking, Batch CG marketplace attestation receipts for provenance, signatures, publisher verification, compatibility, dependency and vulnerability evidence, incident drills, publisher review freshness, trust explanations, and package-count claim blocking, Batch DN marketplace certification-track, supply-chain, hostile lifecycle v2, publisher trust, vulnerability operation, redacted receipt, and false-claim scan receipts, Batch CH browser-provider/usability receipts for provider identity, evidence mode, session partitioning, credential/download/upload boundaries, remote-CDP degradation, recorded-live multi-operator metrics, fail-closed recovery drills, and blocked claims, cockpit-efficiency thresholds, replayable workflow canary failure/recovery/approval-preservation receipts, durable state-kernel safe-checkpoint, durable audit receipt, persisted snapshot, delegated artifact-review receipts, durable-orchestration v2 receipts for lease ownership, idempotent transitions, trigger dedupe, unsafe-resume blocks, artifact adoption gates, production reach/browser/voice receipts for external messaging pairing, privacy redaction, degraded channel recovery, browser provider truth, session partitioning, crash recovery, page-drift replay blocking, guarded voice/media correction/deletion/revocation, Batch CE receipts for live/recorded-live channel attestation, provider identity, consent, pairing, revocation, abuse/rate-limit handling, voice/media capture boundaries, provider fallback, and cross-surface continuity, governed capability-pack hardening receipts, and live-ish fake-provider replay scenarios	broader live-provider and production-like integration proof across real provider behavior, channels, browser transports beyond Batch CH bounded provider/usability receipts, external scheduler exactly-once semantics, broad independent usability, formal external-scale marketplace/package-security proof beyond Batch DN bounded certification-track receipts, and benchmark-facing failure modes	03
Workflow composition and delegation	[ ]	specialists, MCP, skills, delegation foundations, execute-code and clarify/todo/session-search runtime primitives, first-class reusable workflows, starter packs, optional skill packs, skill registry flows, workflow runtimes, Browserbase/browser-relay packaging, direct artifact-to-workflow handoff, thread-aware approval recovery, reusable provider-neutral source review routines, first connector-backed authenticated source actions plus report-publication planning, bounded PR-native code_activity.write create or review actions with fixed-argument guardrails, a dedicated workflow-supervision operator lane, a workspace-level workflow-orchestration lane for multi-session long-running work, explicit long-run workflow state capsules with compacted-step accounting and preserved recovery paths, anticipatory repair drafts, backup-branch candidates, condensation-fidelity reporting, durable scheduled-job run-history receipts, scheduled-job lifecycle audit events, pause/resume no-fire receipts, an M5 operator work layer for jobs/routines/workflows/delegation trust partitions, a named workflow-endurance benchmark suite, a named live workflow-endurance canary suite with replayable delegated-owner/checkpoint/branch/failure-injection/recovery/artifact-comparison/approval-preservation/trust-boundary/audit receipts, a named M5 operating-layer benchmark suite, searchable repository or pull-request engineering-memory bundles over session search plus workflow or approval or audit continuity, an explicit continuity graph across sessions/workflows/approvals/artifacts/notifications/deferred guardian items, operator-readable marketplace-flow composition across starter packs, extension packs, and packaged runbooks, a named m9_governed_ecosystem suite for local extension and connector governance foundations, Batch CA marketplace_grade_capability_lifecycle, governed_capability_lifecycle_v2, and capability_rollback_failure_diagnostics suites for lifecycle mutation, rollback, diagnostics, staged rollout, and cross-family review receipts, Batch CG third_party_marketplace_attestation, marketplace_operations_incident_drill, and publisher_review_and_package_trust suites for recorded-live package attestation and operations, and a governed self-evolution loop for declarative capability assets with eval receipts, explicit change-summary plus review-risk receipts, anti-misevolution preference-collapse blocking, canary-only rollout posture, rollback-ready saved-candidate receipts, and a named governed-improvement benchmark surface	live heartbeat/reactive trigger executors beyond deterministic v2 trigger-dedupe receipts, a full durable workflow state machine, deeper operator-facing step-level workflow debugging, richer delegated artifact/review lifecycle beyond approved-adoption gates, richer authoring ergonomics, more opinionated runtime templates, formal external-scale marketplace/package-security proof beyond Batch DN bounded certification-track receipts, and broader provider-neutral authenticated action coverage across external systems beyond the shipped work-item and pull-request activity contracts	07, 02
Dense interface efficiency	[ ]	guardian workspace with linked state, workflow runs, interventions, audit, trace, fixed composer, persisted layouts, keyboard layout switching, Windows control surface, searchable capability palette, denser operator terminal, active triage, evidence shortcuts, workflow step-focus rows, explicit branch-debug summaries, family-history comparison, direct step/output handoff actions, family-output reuse plus output-comparison drafts, family-row checkpoint drill-in, family-row retry/repair controls, bundled workflow-family next-step planning drafts, denser ancestor/peer/failure-lineage follow-through rows, triage workflow quick actions, direct triage failure-context and recovery controls, a dedicated workflow-supervision lane with history/branch/recovery summaries, a workspace-level workflow-orchestration lane for multi-session supervision, explicit long-run state capsules for compacted workflows, first keyboard-first inspect/approve/continue/latest-branch/best-continuation/comparison/failure/recovery/redirect/workflow/output control, imported reach/governance surfaces, a separate grouped Activity Ledger, and the named cockpit_operator_efficiency_benchmark suite that exposes action/time budgets, no-regression thresholds, confidence-affordance proxy boundaries, and receipt coverage for eleven scripted operator tasks	deeper step-level workflow density, real frontend click/keystroke telemetry, and broader keyboard-first cross-surface control beyond the current step-focus, evidence, branch-debug, workflow-supervision, workspace-level orchestration plus state-capsule compaction, family-history, bundled family-planning, triage quick-action surfaces, and deterministic cockpit-efficiency proxy proof	06, 07
Presence and reach across surfaces	[ ]	browser delivery, proactive queue/bundle delivery, native daemon, actionable desktop presence, browser-side native-notification controls, shared continuity snapshots, runtime route-health visibility, queued-bundle same-thread continuation, browser mode matrix, messaging connectors, automation triggers, node adapters, canvas outputs, explicit channel routing, explicit presence-surface ready/attention continuity across messaging, adapter, and observer surfaces, inventory-backed browser-provider plus node-adapter recovery surfaces with selected/fallback and daemon/network prerequisites, the named channels_presence_device_pairing deterministic suite for channel identity boundaries, external-channel continuity, pairing/revocation fail-closed receipts, mutation boundaries, and abuse/failure review receipts, the named one_excellent_reach_channel_canary suite plus /api/operator/one-reach-channel-canary and cockpit benchmark-proof receipts for native-notification pairing, revocation, health, retry/fallback, same-thread and memory/context continuity, approval handoff, audit trail, degraded-state UI, and no-sprawl boundaries, the named guardian_safe_multimodal_voice suite plus /api/operator/guardian-safe-multimodal-voice surface for voice, TTS/STT, browser vision, image/media analysis, and media delivery governance receipts, Batch BY production_reach_channel_hardening, browser_computer_use_reliability_v2, guardian_safe_voice_media_runtime, plus /api/operator/production-reach-browser-voice receipts for paired external messaging identity, revocation, approval handoff, privacy redaction, degraded recovery, browser provider truth, session partitioning, crash recovery, page-drift replay blocking, and guarded voice/media correction/deletion/revocation paths, Batch CE live_broad_reach_channel_attestation, production_voice_media_provider_runtime, cross_surface_continuity_recovery, plus /api/operator/live-reach-media-proof receipts for mobile push, external messaging, STT, TTS, media analysis, provider identity, evidence mode, consent, pairing, revocation, rate limits, abuse handling, approval handoff, provider-failure fallback, correction/deletion, and cross-surface thread/memory/approval continuity, Batch CL broad_channel_sla_operations, production_voice_media_quality_gates, mobile_execution_continuity, plus /api/operator/production-reach-voice-mobile receipts for provider windows, rate-limit and abuse handling, degraded recovery, coverage-gap claim boundaries, STT/TTS/media quality and latency gates, correction/deletion privacy boundaries, provider-regression fallback, notification approval handoff, mobile action continuity, thread/memory recovery, offline recovery, and revocation fail-closed behavior, Batch DC always_available_reach_operations_v1, voice_media_parity_runtime_v1, mobile_cross_surface_continuity_v1, reach_degraded_recovery_field_campaign, plus /api/operator/always-available-reach-media receipts for selected-channel campaign windows, voice/media quality and latency receipts, cross-surface continuity, degraded-recovery metrics, false/missed delivery metrics, operator repair actions, and redacted receipts, and Batch CH managed_browser_provider_attestation plus browser_computer_use_recovery_drill receipts for local/managed/remote browser provider identity, evidence mode, session partitioning, credential/download/upload boundaries, degradation, and fail-closed browser recovery	broad always-available mobile and messaging reach, production-grade pairing protocols at real scale, full voice/media parity beyond Batch DC bounded selected-channel campaign receipts, safe autonomous browser/computer-use, full browser parity, and continuity across real expanded transport operations remain future work	04, 06

What This Means On develop

• Seraph now has real shipped surfaces on every benchmark axis, including the imported capability families from the Hermes/OpenClaw program.
• Guardian memory, proactive scaffolding, runtime legibility, and capability breadth are now materially stronger than a prototype-only baseline.
• Seraph is still not in a position to claim broad benchmark superiority from shipped implementation alone.
• The shipped repo can now point to explicit benchmark-suite receipts for production parity readiness, production secure-host hardening, live secure-host isolation v2, production-isolation hardening v2, privileged-path red-team gauntlet v2, security-incident recovery drills, guardian memory quality, M6 memory superiority, memory-provider quality gating, M8 guardian intervention quality, live guardian-learning quality, intervention outcome cohorts, memory-provider ecosystem maturity, canonical memory reconciliation v2, provider usefulness regressions, live human outcome quality studies, guardian-learning causal attribution, memory-provider live regression monitors, independent outcome cohort review, task-scoped causal learning, memory-provider parity matrix, longitudinal guardian outcome studies, named baseline memory comparisons, learning safety monitors v2, workflow endurance and repair, live workflow-endurance canary proof, durable workflow state, production durable orchestration, durable workflow engine v2, live external-orchestration attestation, orchestration crash-recovery studies, one-channel reach, production reach-channel hardening, browser/computer-use reliability v2, guardian-safe voice/media runtime, live broad reach channel attestation, production voice/media provider runtime, cross-surface continuity recovery, broad channel SLA operations, production voice/media quality gates, mobile execution continuity, browser-provider attestation, multi-operator usability, browser recovery drills, browser task-breadth/auth-partition/site-drift SLO receipts, final source-backed parity audit, final claim-ledger reconciliation, operator final parity readiness reporting, guardian learning arbitration, governed capability-pack hardening, marketplace lifecycle maturity, live marketplace attestation and operations, production marketplace-security receipts, marketplace registry-corpus operations, production-secure marketplace v1 receipts, third-party package-security certification receipts, marketplace live-corpus operations v2, hostile package lifecycle gauntlet receipts, production operator control parity, production parity train verification, M9 governed ecosystem foundations, planning or retrieval reporting, and governed self-improvement gates instead of only ad hoc eval-scenario memory.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CU benchmark-suite receipts for broad-reach field operations, voice/media quality operations, and bounded reach-SLO behavior, plus Batch DC selected-channel campaign, voice/media runtime, cross-surface continuity, and degraded-recovery campaign receipts, while OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CV benchmark-suite receipts for longitudinal guardian outcome studies, named baseline memory comparisons, and learning safety monitors v2, while guardian intelligence superiority, solved learning, live human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, named baseline wins, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DD benchmark-suite receipts for generalized guardian outcome studies, expanded memory-provider parity matrices, causal learning outcome thresholds, and memory baseline comparisons, while guardian intelligence superiority, solved learning, live-human-outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, named baseline wins, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CW benchmark-suite receipts for operator-control population studies, named cockpit baseline pressure comparisons, and long-work debugging SLOs, while best/world-class cockpit, solved operator-control, approval-transfer, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DE benchmark-suite receipts for operator-control certification, mission-control population v2 telemetry, long-work recovery SLO v2, and operator error detectability, while formal certification, best/world-class cockpit, solved operator-control, approval-transfer solved, tamper-proof audit, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CX benchmark-suite receipts for marketplace registry-corpus operations, continuous vulnerability monitoring, and publisher trust operations, while production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DF benchmark-suite receipts for bounded production-gate coverage, third-party package-security certification-scope records, marketplace live-corpus operations v2, and hostile package lifecycle gauntlets, while production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, formal package-security certification, ecosystem superiority, package-count superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DN benchmark-suite receipts for marketplace production-security certification-track operations, live-ops v2 lifecycle coverage, ecosystem supply-chain enforcement, hostile package lifecycle v2 drills, publisher trust/vulnerability operations, and marketplace false-claim scanning, while production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, formal package-security certification, ecosystem superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DV benchmark-suite receipts for post-DP marketplace lifecycle gap closure, lifecycle operation receipts, package review waiver policy, vulnerability monitoring, hostile package lifecycle v3 drills, rollback/quarantine diagnostics, secure-host audit integration, and marketplace lifecycle false-claim scanning, while production-secure marketplace, solved third-party package security, formal package-security certification, ecosystem superiority, full marketplace parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DW benchmark-suite receipts for post-DP browser/computer-use reliability gap closure, live provider reliability v2, session boundary enforcement v3, credentialed recovery v2, site drift recovery v3, hostile page safety v2, provider degradation v2, and command-backed browser false-claim scanning, while safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer use, OpenClaw-class browser reach, full browser parity, arbitrary credentialed browsing safety, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DX benchmark-suite receipts for post-DQ-DW claim-readiness, board/PR/Project reconciliation, claim-ledger reconciliation, source refresh v5, false-completion scanning, and independent review receipts, while production readiness, full parity, reference-system exceedance, secure/private-by-default, solved durable workflows, solved operator control, production-secure marketplace, safe browser automation, full browser parity, guardian superiority, memory superiority, and broad superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DY benchmark-suite receipts for post-DX live durable orchestration parity proof, recorded-live orchestration windows, crash/restart/failover drills, multi-agent handoff durability, side-effect reconciliation v6, operator recovery controls, and orchestration false-claim scanning v3 through /api/operator/post-dx-live-durable-orchestration, while unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, solved durable workflows, LangGraph-class parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DZ benchmark-suite receipts for post-DX formal secure runtime isolation proof, runtime-attestation evidence v2, credential-broker egress enforcement v3, hostile-chain containment v4, external security review/certification-track v2, secure runtime recovery authority v3, and secure-runtime false-claim scanning v3 through /api/operator/post-dx-formal-secure-runtime-isolation, while secure/private-by-default, production security solved, IronClaw-class secure execution, hardware-backed isolation, TEE/CVM/Wasm/container runtime-isolation, formal security certification, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch EA benchmark-suite receipts for post-DX reach and voice/media parity proof, multi-channel reach reliability v3, voice/media quality latency v3, reach abuse recovery v3, cross-surface reach continuity v3, and reach/voice/media false-claim scanning v3 through /api/operator/post-dx-reach-voice-media-parity-proof, while OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice/media parity, production mobile execution solved, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CY benchmark-suite receipts for browser task breadth, auth/session partition operations, and site-drift recovery SLOs, while safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DG benchmark-suite receipts for bounded browser/computer-use parity evidence, including provider execution caveats, hostile-browser negative cases, clipboard/private-data/network boundaries, and partition certification-scope records, while safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DO benchmark-suite receipts for browser/computer-use production-safety provider modes, safe-target live operations, credentialed test-account recovery, provider parity-candidate degradation, session partition attestation v2, and browser false-claim scanning, while safe browser automation, safe autonomous computer-use, OpenClaw-class browser reach, full browser parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DH benchmark-suite receipts for final DA-DG reconciliation, seven-area production-readiness soak-readiness reconciliation, manual current source-review receipts, exact claim-lift decisions, false-completion scanning, and stale PR closure evidence, while production readiness, full parity, secure/private-by-default, OpenClaw-class reach, IronClaw-class execution, solved operator control, solved learning, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DI benchmark-suite receipts for durable queue/scheduler leases, worker failover, replay authority, distributed recovery operations, side-effect correctness v4, accelerated fixture soak receipts with missing-live-window markers, operator recovery controls, and false-claim scans, while unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, continuous live-soak completion, solved durable workflows, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DQ benchmark-suite receipts for post-DP durable orchestration gap closure, multi-agent handoff recovery, scheduler crash/restart recovery, side-effect reconciliation v5, and orchestration false-claim scan v2 through /api/operator/post-dp-durable-orchestration, while unconditional exactly-once scheduling, crash-proof orchestration, solved durable workflows, LangGraph-class parity, production readiness, full parity, and exceeded-reference-system wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DS benchmark-suite receipts for selected native-notification and websocket reach/channel gap-closure, degraded recovery, guardian timing/restraint continuity, voice/media privacy fallback, staged channel gaps, and false-claim scanning, while OpenClaw-class reach, complete channel coverage, always-available operation, voice/media parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch DT benchmark-suite receipts for post-DP guardian learning and memory gap closure, long-horizon learning quality v2, memory behavior ablation v2, memory-provider operation v2, learning-safety regression v2, and guardian-memory false-claim scanning v2 through /api/operator/post-dp-guardian-learning-memory-gap-closure, while guardian intelligence superiority, solved learning, live-human-outcome superiority, generalized outcome superiority, memory superiority, full memory-provider parity, production readiness, full parity, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The shipped repo can also point to Batch CZ benchmark-suite receipts for post-CQ claim-ledger reconciliation, static 2026-06-11 reference-system source receipts with external Critic/Contrarian reachability review, clean local false-completion scanning, and required external GitHub PR/issue scan and Project-verification gates through /api/operator/post-cq-claim-readiness, while full parity, production readiness, security, browser, marketplace, operator-control, guardian-superiority, memory-superiority, exactly-once/crash-proof, hardware-backed/runtime-isolation, and superiority wording stay blocked by the claim ledger.
• The biggest implementation gaps now cluster around formal hardware-backed or externally certified privileged execution isolation beyond Batch DZ bounded runtime-attestation, egress, hostile-chain, review-track, unsupported-boundary, recovery, and false-claim receipts; unconditional exactly-once/crash-proof production orchestration beyond Batch DY recorded-live, failover, handoff, side-effect, operator-control, and false-claim receipts; solved operator-control and best/world-class cockpit claims beyond Batch DU bounded post-DP operator debugging/recovery-control receipts; production-secure marketplace and solved package-security proof beyond Batch DV bounded lifecycle, waiver, vulnerability-monitoring, hostile-lifecycle, rollback/quarantine diagnostic, secure-host integration, and false-claim receipts; blanket safe browser automation/full browser parity beyond Batch DW bounded provider-degradation, boundary, recovery, site-drift, hostile-page, artifact-provenance, and false-claim receipts; complete always-available reach and full voice/media parity beyond Batch EA bounded multi-channel reliability, quality/latency, abuse recovery, continuity, coverage-gap, and false-claim receipts; and generalized outcome superiority, solved learning, memory superiority, or full memory-provider parity beyond Batch DT bounded long-horizon, ablation, provider-operation, safety-regression, and false-claim scan receipts.

Acceptance Checklist

• Every benchmark axis from research has an explicit implementation owner.
• Every benchmark axis says what is shipped on develop and what is still missing.
• The benchmark mirror has been refreshed after the five-wave capability import program.
• No axis should be called effectively “won” in implementation docs without shipped proof on develop.
• The strategic roadmap and active GitHub execution layer still map back to the gaps named here.